This is the blog of the "Revelation and Resistance" course at Hendrix College. Your comments are welcomed and invited.
Thursday, March 31, 2011
In Order to Fight the Beast, One Needs an Opposing Ideology.
Stringfellow #2
In the opening of our reading for today Stringfellow brings up a comparison of George Orwell’s 1984 and compares it to Demonic tactics in Revelation. For Stringfellow Babel is also violent and means ‘rumor’, which is also intriguing when you think about it in terms of the whore of Babylon and who is a woman, who gossips about spreading lies and false hopes. The cursing and conjuring section was also interesting too because he brings up a point of how even after testimonies are given about people, like the black panthers, they are later proven false. Yet even though they are proven false the cursing is still evident it cannot be taken back. Even though this cursing is bad it goes hand in hand with other evils such as lies and violence which cannot survive by themselves.
One of my questions for Stringfellow is if they did not speak about the Antichrist or were to shy to do so in his Episcopal Church then what did he do with that? Since in our first reading he was so adament about how we as Americans and Christians are ignorant or scared to read the Book of Revelation.
I do however, like his section on escaping Naziism and how we can live humanly in the face of death. He said that these people who saved other Jews or resisted the Nazi’s did so to keep their sanity. To resist is to put up a fight, a fight of silence is still aggressive and still gets the job done without any blood shed. These people who were involved in the resistance were courageous and also normal people who tried every means of surviving and sometimes the only way to keep that sanity is to fight for it but not always in the way we think.
Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Babel... and the gifts of the Spirit?
Stringfellow speaks of the reality of Babel, a force that signifies many negative concepts like: the allurements of the principalities, the militant violence present in U.S. policy and in the U.S. value system. On page 106 Stringfellow provides another one of his many strings (no pun intended) of words that serve as examples of the message he attempts to convey. Amongst some of those words we can find “redundancy (in speech)”, “blasphemy”, “falsehood”, and the like. He says that the city of Babel is Babylon. Babel pretty much represents any and all evil found in history and the world. Instances such as the Roman emperor worship, the genocide of WWII, racism and dehumanization are all featured as examples of what Babel is. Another form of Babel is institutionalized evil, such as evil government. He writes that “Essentially, Babel targets the faculties of comprehension- sanity and conscience- which distinguish human beings from other creatures” (107). In Stating this Stringfellow clarifies that in essence Babel’s role is to rob human beings of their dignity, power, and identity as such. Babel manifests itself violently. Here I recall an argument made in class by one of my fellow classmates (the Philosophy major), who noted that the conceptualization of “violence” is a fairly recent occurrence, as in olden days (such as in the days of the Roman Empire) what now is characterized as “violence” was separated into various categories of evil such as “incest”, “murder”, etc.
Another section of this second part of the book that interested me highly is that where he discusses “glossolalia” (on page 146). For one thing I had never known there was a dictionary/official term for this occurrence. I just witnessed this phenomenon at my church over spring break. A preacher from a different congregation was invited to give a sermon to the church’s youth, and once he was done his wife stood up and asked if anyone needed to be prayed for, at which time several people proceeded to go to the front of the church. She went on to pray for almost half the congregation during the next two hours, and she predicted many things for many of them. For example, she told one of my friends she was going to be a pastor, and another one that he would leave and do work in three more cities. One of my friends started speaking incomprehensive words very loudly while she was being prayed for. I had only heard the term “speaking in tongues” before, and had not encountered a happening similar to it. Thanks to Stringfellow I now understand this was an instance of “glossolalia”. I certainly still have my doubts about charismatic gifts, I have seen also a couple of pastors speak what seemed to me to be incomprehensible gibberish when praying for people, and I suspect this is not a real language (although I do not know how Greek sounds so maybe they spoke Greek?) And also, I have heard before that there needs to be one who understands amongst those gathered in order for someone to speak in tongues. Anyhow, I appreciate that Stringfellow called believers towards discernment and caution when encountering these topics. His is such a radical and interestingly comprehensive approach to the theme of the gifts of the Spirit, and I quite enjoyed it.
America becoming the New Babylon
The Gift of Discernment
Humans are constantly being influenced by their surroundings. We do not exist in a vacuum and our behaviors reflect that. Stringfellow’s discussion of all the propaganda that comes from principalities in chapter 4 reminded me of our trip to the mall, the 24 hour cable news channels we have today, and many psychology studies that deal with the great influence even minute stimuli has on human behavior. For Stringfellow these demoralize and dehumanize people possibly by distracting them from others. I’m never quite sure what Stringfellow is talking about we he say to act humanly, but in the last reading he did say you cannot act humanly without being around others and we’re all connected because we’re all caught up in systems. But does that make being with other people a principality?
Stringfellow never really says what to do about all of this, but just to be aware of it and be realistic through the spiritual gift of discernment. For Stringfellow this means being sensitive to “the Word of God indwelling in all creation” and “being realistic about death’s vitality.” (p. 139). We resist death by using the gift of discernment. His definition of death is unclear to me, but it may be so broad that it includes everything that in the systematic powers, so basically everything. I really wish he would define his terms more clearly. So discerning seems to be the act of knowing that the systems are death and speaking the truth. Which is? The Word? But even the Bible does not really know God’s judgement (p. 56). In the face of the world and its systems that we cannot escape all we can do is be aware of that fact and know there is no hope, but there is somehow hope in that? I don’t really get it, but then Stringfellow would say I’m caught up in the demonic powers and principalities.
The confusion with which we might greet Stringfellow's proscriptive but not prescriptive account would, on his view, be a sign of our very thralldom to the principalities in that our thoughts and actions, our ability to determine resistance and live humanly, are circumscribed by conformity to those principalities and powers which he rails against. Such a view, one of the need to escape our entrapment in the thinking of the dominant system or that of everydayness, can be found in 20th century thinkers as diverse as Dewey and Debord. Guy Debord, in his Society of the Spectacle, formulates in a similar manner what I believe is the upshot of Stringfellow's argument. Two claims which I think express this are as follows. First, he asserts that "the spectacle’s essential character reveals it to be a visible negation of life — a negation that has taken on a visible form." In other words, the spectacle, society in the modern era, is one constituted by the negation of life (in Stringfellow's terms, death). Second, Debord, a political radical, notes that in a world of separation and the negation of life, resistance must "embody a radical separation from the world of separation."
A new way to be human
Tuesday, March 29, 2011
Can America be Babylon and Jerusalem?
He does however, in the first few chapters make very good, well thought out points that truly make one think. We have talked about America being associated with Babylon many many times in this class, but point that America sees itself as something of the opposite. God loves America, therefore, American Christians are who other Christians should strive to be like. The irony in this is so interesting because what will happen when Babylon (America) falls?
This would be an obvious call to change America, change its ideals and the way it sees itself compared to the rest of the world. Stringfellow does to a good job when describing this conundrum.
Privatization of religion
Monday, March 28, 2011
The "Fallen" College Empire
But even though Stringfellow considers Babylon to be a metaphor for America, much of American Christendom ironically considers itself to be Zion. This idea is widespread and is obvious in texts like Are We Living in the End Times? He proposes that this is the case because American Christians are “biblically illiterate…grossly naïve or remarkably misinformed about the fall” (19). Americans get the lighter view of the “Fall” from church than what the text warns of, which is that, at least in our case, “the Fall is the locus of America” (19).
I appreciate the disclaimer he makes about the American Apocalypse not necessarily being what he calls the Apocalypse. “Well, these are apocalyptic days for America, I believe, but an American Apocalypse is not likely to be the terminal event of history” (33). I’m interested to see exactly how he felt we should live in spite of this condemnation of America.
America is Babylon?
the blame
Message Not Received...
New Babylon
As Stringfellow points out, Revelation depicts the fall of the greatest power in the world. The fall of Babylon is violent and the city is completely destroyed. However, there is rejoicing in heaven over the city's destruction. America being the so powerful and wealthy the parallels between it and Babylon are clear. In this light, how can some modern Christians insist that America is a Christian nation or even “one nation under God?”
Perhaps Americans do not realize that this nation is not Jerusalem. God does not bless America as so many bumper stickers and t-shirts claim. Making this claim is like confusing Babylon and Jerusalem. Stringfellow says “Babylon is the city of death, Jerusalem is the city of salvation... Babylon [is] doomed, Jerusalem [is] redeemed.” Christians today need to realize that America is much more like Babylon than is accredited. Revelation is about living as a Christian in a fallen society that only God can restore; nations do not give freedom, God gives freedom. Perhaps Jeremiah Wright's words held some truth: “God damn America for as long as she acts like she is God and she is supreme.”
Strongly asserting the rootedness of faith in one's historical and existential location, Stringfellow's account demands a collective praxis which simultaneously avoids the pitfalls I found to be present in Kraybill's text. By explicitly stating that the "Biblical witness" does not offer ethical axioms, but rather a way of life, as well as by substantively establishing how it is that the historical circumstances which generated the text can be related to those of the present, I am willing to grant greater plausibility to his account. Moreover, I tend to agree with the thrust of his argument, in terms of understanding an ethos of death (more accurately, an absence of ethos, i.e., nihilism)pervading sociality in the contemporary era, albeit obscured in everydayness. However, not being a theist, I am unwilling to stretch such an understanding of contemporary life into a way for understanding all societies (or principalities) in retrospect. To read this concept into all prior civilizations seems either erroneous or to liquidate it of argumentative force.
Principalities and Powers versus Personal Efficacy
On page eighteen of An Ethic for Christians and Other Aliens in a Strange Land, William Stringfellow writes, “any social concern of human beings which neglects of refuses to deal with the principalities with due regard for their own dignity is delusive, while any social change predicated upon mere human action- whether prompted by so-called social gospel or motivated by some pietism- is doomed.”
“The awful ambiguity of Babylon’s fallenness is expressed consummately in Babylon’s delusion that she is, or is becoming, Jerusalem . . . this is the vocational crisis, really, which every nation in history endures.”
I really like this quote, primarily because it reminds me so much of conversations we have often had in class concerning the role of American Christianity as well as American politics. Many fundamentalist Christians, and if I may venture to say those believing in rapture theory, have a distinct belief that Americanism and Christian belief systems are on and the same and furthermore, that American Christians will inherit the promised new Jerusalem. Strangely, America is an extremely powerful, individualistic country whose inhabitants, generally speaking, are far from qualifying as the “oppressed masses.” This reality is drastically different that those humbled and God-fearing people for whom Jerusalem has been set aside.
In reality, most Americans are slaves to technology and materialism, which are not often perceived as our masters. This is much the case of Babylon. As Stringfellow argues, it seems to me that America qualifies as Babylon in the narrative of Revelation, not the homeland of a great number of Christians who are oppressed by tangible powers, but by powers that they do not even recognize.
The power structure of all nations seems to remarkably oppress Christians by requiring allegiance to the said power structure, something I believe American Christians often fail to recognize. It is not the devil and sex and drugs which are oppressing good people, but the entire American society itself.
But now I wonder, how is there society, with no institutions? With no military, no civil services branches, no government, no Church, how does society function? Without society, how do we as humans begin to interact? I am intrigued to see where Stringfellow goes with his philosophy, because it seems to me he is suggesting that true Jerusalem, means removing oneself from these institutions, but is anarchy really the solution he is proposing?
Sunday, March 27, 2011
Saint Stringfellow
Friday, March 25, 2011
Moral Poverty and Serving Death
Death is the master of Babylon. Unless actively worked against, we as Americans serve death. Whether I am sacrifcing myself to the principalities and powers through my labor or watching college basketball on CBS, I am serving the legions of Death. This is disturbing. When I am watching basketball I am relaxing and when I working and paying my taxes I am just supporting my family or at least that is what it seems like I am doing. In a way Stringfellow reminds me of the Matrix because the world is not truly as it seems. My labor goes to a corporation whose sole goal is survival or besting death. My taxes go to fund wars across the Middle East and therefore just the fact that I pay taxes to the US government, I am serving death by helping her claim more lives. By watching basketball, I am not watching Babylon/Rome/America and I am therefore being won over by bread and circuses. As uncomfortable as Stringfellow may make me feel, he is hard to refute. Do we as Americans serve the great whore of Babylon unknowingly? Is Stringfellow the blue pill?
Stringfellow is incredibly deep and I have a hard time fully comprehending all of his ideas but if he is right and I am to actively fight the fallenness at all times, how do I survive? Maybe the next readings will provide these answers but I am at a loss as to what I should do to live a biblical ethic. Do I cancel my cable or just watch C-Span and then constantly right letters to my representative who is "quite ordinarily moral?" (Stringfellow 89) Do I quit my job and let my family starve so that they can be freed from serving Death? Would letting my family literally succomb to death be worse than figuratively serving death? I see many connections between John of Patmos and Strongfellow but I do not know how I am to live the message that either of these men are teaching. I see that Stringfellow went to Harvard and practiced law and wrote a book and is wearing a courdoroy suit on the cover of his book. It would seem that he participates in the economy of the empire. Does that mean he is like Jezebel from Rev 2:20 or has he found a way to use the Empire and live a biblical morality?
I find Stringfellow to be fascinating and I like his message but it is so complex that I have many more questions than answers after this reading.
Tuesday, March 15, 2011
Reading as a Whole
I chose to look at Boring’s commentary because I noticed that the cover looked familiar, then realized that it is part of a series of commentaries that I had encountered previously in Dr. Sanders’ Exodus class. The introduction to this commentary is lengthy, comprising about one-third of the book. In it Boring explains that his book is not meant to be taken apart and used as a guide in which you look up certain passages to find a specific answer. Instead, he says that his commentary is to be read as a whole work, just as the book of Revelation should not be taken apart and should be considered only as an ongoing narrative. Having read this, I still had to follow the guidelines of this assignment, and so proceeded to look up the section that discusses chapters two and three. Now that I have this thought in my head I do think it must have also been necessary to read all the other commentaries as a whole work. Certainly there is much that one misses by just choosing certain areas, but also time does not allow for more.
In the opening paragraphs that speak of chapters two and three (beginning in page 85), Boring takes on the same message: that the letters John wrote must not be seen as separate letters going to different churches, but instead as a whole: as one letter directed to all. He explains that the messages to the churches are meant for all the churches in Asia, although it is unclear why these particular seven churches were chosen. He does mention that the number seven signifies completion, a notion that is now becoming ingrained in our heads. Boring notes how these seven letters are written in a straightforward fashion, and also include messages relevant to churches of this world. It is in chapter four, he notes, that the reader is transported to the world of John’s visions. Something that stood out to me was in page 88, where he talked about the Christological ascriptions of each letter. I suppose I had not been paying attention but I had not noticed most of the interestingly different ways in which Christ is talked about in each letter, as well as throughout the book of Revelation.
In his introduction Boring also states that the book of Revelation was meant to be read aloud, and in the context of worship. In this I think he agrees with Kraybill, whose main focus has also been worship.
Monday, March 14, 2011
Catholic Worker Movement
Allegiance, Belief, and Practice
In another class I’m in, we’ve discussed how what has become Christendom is very different from the Christianity that Jesus taught us to follow. On page 187, Kraybill offers the same kind of critique when he says, “we are less likely to let issues and perspectives of our own generation eclipse the shared wisdom of saints through the ages,” if we understand that our worship of God transcends time, culture, etc. Kraybill suggests, if Christians were to support the claim that worship of God transcends everything, then we wouldn’t dismiss sections of the scripture. Instead of finding ways to interpret the Bible to make unethical actions the government or people do seem ethical, Kraybill seems to imply that we need to eliminate that which doesn’t fit into what scripture says we should be doing.
This idea also seems to be apparent when Kraybill talks about deeds being important just as belief is. Like Revelation says, we will be judged according to our works that are recorded in the books. Those who try to get by “believing” but not putting into practice what Jesus has preached may think that they have great glory in heaven waiting for them, but in reality, God has been watching, and they will be given what they deserve.
I’m fond of the section in which Kraybill says, “it is Christ, not fellow Christians, who finally removes unfaithful congregations.” So many people try to prove that other sects or other religions are so terribly wrong and that they are the ones who got the message correct. I agree with Kraybill’s quote because we aren’t God, and no matter how much we may think we are, when it comes down to it, I’m glad someone other than myself or other humans will be in charge of judging humanity.
Upon reading the question “Do governments we know today act more like ‘God’s servant’ or like the beast ‘uttering haughty and blasphemous words,’” in Kraybill’s text, I find myself reminded of our class last week when we asked ourselves similarly, whether the state is dangerous to the church. I have thought about this a lot lately, trying to decide what I personally feel about our government and the way it interacts with the Christian belief system and Chapter 10 in Apocalypse and Allegiance, brought me back to it once more.
Often, you hear leaders in our government discuss how our nation was built on Christian principles and people argue that America and Christianity are one in the same. This has always been a problem for me. Since high school, I have been frustrated by anyone who claimed that there was one “right” religion or “right” God. Similarly, I have long felt the same way about people who insist their political beliefs are “right,” as opposed to other ways of thinking. To me, people arguing that Americanism and Christianity exist harmoniously, and that they necessarily should, are making both of these claims. Furthermore, it almost appears they are insisting that somehow, American Christians are God’s chosen people-this deeply disturbs me.
I believe one reason this does disturb me is that I actually do feel many American governmental practices do not strike me as particularly in line with the teachings of Christ. In our materialistic and individualistic society, people often strive for their own successes and betterment rather than for community wellness. My personal belief is that social welfare would be an important component of the Christian effort, one that seems often lost to those who insist they abide by God and America. In a country where enormous amounts of the GDP are spent on defense, it seems strange to claim Jesus’ teachings of love and peace as an integral part of our democracy.
In reflecting on this I feel many conservatively minded Americans believe our government is “God’s servant,” but I feel if one were to take a closer look, this claim is unfounded. But does this necessarily make our government a pawn of “the beast,” or does it just mean that to declare allegiance to a government body is in conflict with fully aligning oneself with a religion? That, I am still debating.
What the Hell?
Revelation’s description of Judgement Day includes the destruction of evil, in the form of the beast and the Devil, and the judgement of all humanity. Kraybill calls this destruction a “definitive stroke of divine justice.” When the dead are resurrected and judged by God, it is by their behaviors not their belief. Kraybill says this is similar to what Jesus said about helping others in Matthew 25:31. This passage of Revelation is very interesting to me because most Christians I know today believe in salvation by faith not salvation by works. Witherington points out that there is more than one book used in judgement. One is the book of deeds and the other is the book of life. The Book of Life is used to judge humanity because believer’s deeds may fall short of the requirement of good work to qualify for salvation. This makes faith in Christ look like a back up plan for people who aren’t very good at living decently. However, those who took part in the first resurrection scene in Revelation were the martyrs. According to Blount the work that saved them was witnessing for Christ. Perhaps resisting the Roman Empire could qualify as a good work.
Witherington and Blount say that the lake of fire is eternal punishment not momentary annihilation. Blount says John believes that mercy and grace for humanity cannot exist without justice. Evil deserves justice and to him justice means destruction. In Blount’s view those who suffer the second death receive spiritual, not physical, torment. They suffer because they are separated from God who is the source of all goodness in the world. This keeps God from being very involved in the eternal punishment of evil. It is simply His absence that causes pain, not His creation of a physical hell. This seems like a modern interpretation that attempts to reconcile God with the violence of eternal suffering. I doubt John was thinking about what hell was like for his stand ins for Roman authority.
The End Purpose
Revelation 22:17: The Spirit and the bride say, “Come.” And let everyone who hears say, “Come.” And let everyone who is thirsty come. Let anyone who wishes take the water of life as a gift.
In order to better understand the end of the book of Revelation, I looked at the commentary by Brian K. Blount and at Kraybill’s observations in Apocalypse and Allegiance. Kraybill’s ideas on p.180 were really helpful for me through his explanation of what eschatology actually means for Christianity. Christian eschatology is more about he end (purpose) of history than about the terminus (finishing point) of history. The eschatology in Revelation points more towards living out God’s commands in the present time rather than waiting around for Jesus’ second coming. Similarly, Blount says that John’s message in Revelation were “intended to impel his hearers and readers into appropriate contemporary action” appealing to the “imminence of God’s intervention not to offer a timeline but to encourage a sense of urgency.”
It seems that contemporary Christians have skewed the apocalyptic message of Revelation so much that we no longer actually understand what the purpose of Revelation was for John. He was writing with a sense of urgency to his audience, very convinced that Jesus could be coming at any second. Before reading both of these commentaries on Revelation, I felt like this mindset of Jesus coming at any moment and living with a sense of urgency created a troubling tension with Christians and the world. It seems though that Revelation is actually focused on the act of worship, and that through living in this sense of urgency, Christians are more centered on hope than anything else. Kraybill and Blount both insist that instead of being consumed with a timeline, early Christians and contemporary Christians find hope in John’s message that can sustain them through the suffering they experience in the world.
Empire
Thursday, March 10, 2011
God has chosen the side of poor, oppressed people.
One of the distinctive contributions of liberation theology is the idea of God's "preferential option for the poor." While the popularizer of this term (and one of the fathers of liberation theology), Gustavo Gutierrez, makes clear that it does not suggest an exclusion from God's love of anyone, it does mean that God is on the side of the marginalized. Boesak picks up this theme when he asserts that "God has chosen the side of poor, oppressed people," and is set "against" Rome, the oppressor.
It seems in many ways like an obvious point to me. But it reminded me of a small controversy brewing in the denomination to which I belong, the Presbyterian Church (USA). Lest Dr Williamson have any more cause to make fun of me as a "polity nerd," I'll spare the background details, but suffice it to say that our church is currently voting on whether or not to adopt a theological statement that was written by South African theologians during apartheid, the Belhar Confession.
Most of the opposition to this adoption, at least that I've witnessed, has come from conservative corners in our church. Among their many arguments (including, coincidentally - or perhaps not - that the confession can be interpreted to advocate the ordination of queer people, based on statements that Boesak himself has made) is that this confession puts forth a liberation theology understanding of God's relationship to the poor. As a publication from the group Presbyterians for Renewal argues:
Another problematic statement is “We believe … that God, in a world full of injustice and enmity, is in a special way the Lord of the destitute, the poor and the wronged … that God calls the church to follow him in this; …” That sounds right, but it isn’t. The Lord cares for the poor, the destitute, the wronged, but the Bible does not say he is their Lord in a special way. God calls his people to care for the destitute, the poor and the wronged, not because he is Lord of the poor in a special way but because he is Lord of the Church in a special way!Perhaps it's not such an obvious point. I'll be clear: I disagree with PfR on a lot of things and I disagree with them on Belhar and liberation theology. But thinking through the ways in which the debate continues even in my own denomination helped me to remember to place Boesak in his context as a black South African resisting apartheid and to remember his methods and assumptions. Contextualizing his writing doesn't mean I discount it, but it ensures that I'm able to understand it more fully.