Monday, February 28, 2011

There is much to be found

Horsley explains that the text has to do with political as much as religious themes. This is clear in the text itself, which speaks of empires (Media, Greece, Babylon, Persia) and their rule. Horsley corroborates what was said in class, that Daniel is written in the form of an ex eventu prophecy. I thought it interesting that Daniel 7-2 also included a few references to the Messiah (anointed one). I know very little about ideas of the Messiah that are found in the Hebrew Bible, and thus have no knowledge of the view of Jews towards this topic today. This left me wondering if there is a special meaning attached to the Messiah being mentioned here, as well as the presence of other angels (Michael, Gabriel). On that note, I also happen to know very little about angels. Many appear here as messengers and translators of Daniels visions.

Horsley researches other prophetic books in the Bible (Jeremiah, Zechariah) in order to find parallels with the book of Daniel, although Daniel as we know is featured in the “Writings”. The parallels that Horsley draws with Enoch’s Animal Vision (and other Enochic texts) are also interesting to note. That is something that I appreciate about Horsley’s writing, his thick documentation which draws upon diverse sources to create appealing conclusions.

I would like to learn of other interpretations of the book of Daniel. Surely Horsley’s is not the only one. The text is so rich in imagery, I imagine extensive commentaries must be available somewhere.

For Horsley in the end it comes down to a struggle of political oppression of empires, and the need for the assertion of the sovereignty of God.

The Downside of Contextualization

The contextualization of the apocalyptic texts is certainly relevant, and Horsley provides us with a way to see the historic implications that are deeply important to understand. However, I do not see these texts as certainly only about their historical contexts, in fact that would make little sense. If this was a revolt of the scribes, then why would they be writing such symbolic and image heavy text for a Jewish audience that is probably mostly illiterate? Why would scribes feel the need to “revolt” at all within the texts when this would obviously only bring comfort to a select few individuals who would be able to understand the imagery? It seems to me that if the scribe wrote this he must have had a metaphorical inclination, otherwise what is the point other than making his intellectual scribe buddies think better about the state of things? I am not trying to limit Horsley's argument here, certainly his thesis is important, however since what this means for the future is not included, we are missing a big part of the story. This would be like analyzing Full Metal Jacket as only a product of the situation in Vietnam at the time. While it is certainly the case that Full Metal Jacket was a reflection on these events, it also certainly makes a statement about the dehumanization that goes on in any war in any time period. While I suspect that Horsley would be conscious of this problematic part in his thesis, and probably is limited to length because of his necessity to prove his scholarly arguments, I also think that this political dimension of these apocalyptic texts and what they mean for today is complex, and deserves a more deeper analysis by scholars. Horsley alludes to this a bit in his conclusion for Chapter 5 “the religious and political-economic dimensions were inseparable.”I think that the the apocalyptic texts have a political message that needs to read, and maybe could apply to us today.


P.S. Although not relevant to this analysis of the reading, I decided it would be fun to post a song by the band Hellhammer, who use a lot of biblical imagery in their songs. This one in particular deals with the apocalypse, so it makes some references to characters mentioned in Revelation such as Gog and Magog. However, these bands often reverse this imagery and make Satan the eventual winner in this cosmic battle. Even black metal guys are creating there own interpretations of the apocalyptic texts (even if it isn't very faithful to the biblical text)!





To read the lyrics, click here!

2 Different Writers...Maybe, But Central Message..Yes

As talked about in class, it is extremely common and reasonable to divide the book of Daniel into two separate parts. The division is usually made between the court stories in Chapters 1-6 and the visions in Chapters 7-12. The reason for this is because of the overlapping time periods, the change in style from tales to visions, and also the change from Daniel being an interpreter to requiring interpretation. Even though there are multiple ways to view Daniel, I am fairly convinced this is the most plausible.

Although some might argue that the two sections contain two different themes due to the presumption of two different writers and the presumption of the difference in dating of these sections of Daniel, I believe it is legitimate to say that they could also contain a central theme and be looked at with unity. The two sections might have a different style and different points to be emphasized, but there is also some similarities within them. This can be seen in the depiction of emperial power being "evil" in chapters 7-12 (The visions of the beasts) and also the persecution of believers in chapters 1-6 (Daniel thrown in the lions den and the fiery furnace). This leads me to believe that maybe the two "so different" parts have a quite similar message of the inevitable triumph of the kingdom of God, and also a message of God's assurance of sovereignty over all of mankind and history. Hence, it can be concluded that the rise and fall of empires is in His hands and that in the future His Kindgdom will prevail over all others.

It obviously makes sense to separate the two parts of Daniel when you want to look at them historically, but I believe it is permissible to view them in a certain type of unity when regarding them religiously.

Historical Context and Reader Accessibility

I start out in a lot of the readings we do thinking that I don’t have enough background in Biblical studies to fully comprehend the arguments many of these authors make, but it was a problem I anticipated and one that can usually be at least partially remedied by taking the time to look up and read verses when they’re referenced. More and more often with Horsley though, I’m finding less of a problem with Biblical context and more of a problem with historical context. He seems to have a fairly exhaustive knowledge of the time period during which Daniel and Enoch were presumably written, but therein lies the problem: his knowledge is not necessarily common knowledge, and therefore I feel like his credibility is at stake among readers who may have little to no knowledge of ancient “Near East” history or the generally accepted time-frames that various scriptures are placed into. Many people tend to think of history in terms of the cultural contexts and popular myth they have learned in their lives. For example, it is easy to blur most historical periods from the Sumerians/Babylonians through the Greeks/Romans into one long era of philosophical and civilizational advancements. Biblical “history” seems like something completely other, almost as if it happened in another world rather than throughout the same periods and at the same times as many of the histories we learn in school. Without the proper specific knowledge of context, therefore, readers are totally dependent on Horsely’s accounts. I can’t help but wonder, under these circumstances, whether he can claim any more credibility than LaHaye and Jenkins and their ilk without at least pointing his readers toward sources of non-biblical historical information that corroborate the arguments he makes in interpreting Daniel and Enoch in socio-historical context.I'd really be curious to learn more about the global context of the periods he's focusing on, in the interests of my own interpretation.

Catch-22

I know we talked about the differences between Daniel 1-6 and Daniel 7-12, but I was really surprised at how different these halves actually were. In Daniel 1-6, Daniel is generally discussed in the third person and stories are told about him, whereas in 7-12, the narrative aside from the interpretations, is in first person; Daniel actually talks about himself in the second half of the book. For me this is a fascinating disconnect, because it seems to resonate with ideas I’ve long held about the Bible-to read as a whole and singular book is generally a failure to appreciate the independence of each book, which at one point, did exist autonomously. In the case of Daniel, perhaps it can be successfully thought of as two separate texts.

After reading Daniel 7-12, I’m also sold on Horsley’s argument that these books must be considered in their historical and political context, rather than just a religious one. He does his argument justice by citing similar themes within other books of Bible, as well as other Judean “apocalyptic” texts. He even goes as far to discuss other mythologies and how the prophetic nature of Daniel 7-12 relates to some of these popular ideas and attempts to cast doubt upon others.

In trying to be as unbiased as possible, I think these above methods, as well as Horsley’s treatment of Daniel as a whole rather than disjointed verses, makes his argument stronger than that of rapture theologians. He actually seems to have a better understanding of Daniel as an independent ancient text, as opposed to one which establishes the framework for the prophecy of separate and unrelated (at least in terms of ancient times) book in the Bible (Revelation). For me, these facts alone make his argument more plausible.

Still, I think that rapture theology, or at least current views of “apocalypse,” are more appealing to some due to the accessibility of the respective viewpoints. Horsley’s line of reasoning requires deeper knowledge of ancient history (and I would argue, of various ancient religions) in order to fully appreciate its subtleties, whereas rapture theology requires little to no knowledge of ancient history, other religions, and perhaps even Christianity to be understood. Unfortunately, if a person lacks the previous background or a commitment to learning about ancient political and social climates, Horsley’s argument loses some ground, and popular views of apocalyptic texts seem more “user-friendly,” thus remaining the popular view.

Actually

Horsley is often a straightforward kind of a guy. By the third paragraph of the chapter, he's laid out his thesis:
It is clear in the visions and explicit in their interpretations that the focus is on the overwhelming political power of empires, on their escalating violence and destruction. Insofar as religion and politics are inseparable in antiquity, moreover, the violent measures that the imperial forces take to suppress religious practices are also attacks on a subject people's whole traditional way of life.
Now, I was getting ready to draw upon the past three weeks of anti-oppression training we've been doing in Unity to write this blog entry on systems of privilege and oppression and the danger that comes when we, as people of enormous and significant privilege, appropriate the experiences of oppressed people. I was prepared to think about how we - many of whom are members of the religion largely treated as "mainstream" in the dominant culture, all of whom benefit to some degree from the various empires in which we live - might find some sort of meaning in a text written by those who were religiously oppressed by the forces of empire.

But the thing is, I'm an RS major and the department, in its wisdom, decreed that I am required to take Theories and Research in Religion and strongly recommended that I take it last semester and so I did. I didn't really enjoy it - no one does - but I think I did learn from it. We spent a lot of time thinking and talking about psychological, literary, sociological, historical, etc. understandings of religious phenomena. Applying ways of thinking from other disciplines is something we must do - there is no distinct "religious studies" method - but it always comes with a trepidation that we are explaining or, less appealingly, reducing the phenomena. Are we giving, for example, Judaism the respect it deserves when we argue that health concerns peculiar to that time and location were factors in the development of kosher and other purity laws? It's a fine line.

It's a line that Horsely treads when he argues that the text of Daniel is "actually" about Hellenistic rule in a very particular way. That the beasts "actually" represent imperial kings and the horns "actually" represent imperial power. He makes a convincing argument. And he's careful to say at the front end that he's not excluding the possibility of "actual" visionary experiences. But he's not real worried about that possibility. For him, this text isn't actually about a vision, despite the claim the text seems to be making otherwise.

Taken in context, I'm willing to believe that it's very likely that this text was composed to communicate something of the political climate at the time and not to report on a first-hand visionary experience. But I do have some methodological qualms. Blame Dr Gorvine.

Some cool title

Horsley opens chapter five pointing out religion and politics as inseparable as imperial forces suppress religious practices. I find this to be an interesting starting point, which we have discussed some in class already. In our society we have a separation of church and state, but as mentioned in class, is there actually a separation between these two?

Horlsey breaks down Daniel 7-12 using his literary-historical point of view dismissing other mythical interpretations viewing Daniel as a survey of history. He holds strong to his ideology providing evidence to support his argument and dismiss differing views as any good scholar would do. For example, his interpretation of Daniel 7 as he dismisses the interpretation utilizing the Canaanite myth of the beasts rising from the sea as a symbolism of the power of chaos. Horsley does a spectacular job supporting this literary-historical point of view in interpretations of this "apocalyptic" style of writing. This view point does require a significant amount of knowledge of Biblical writings and history of the times. I think this does effect the number of people who do accept and support the claims he makes. It seems more intended for academia than the religious public.

As for the book of Daniel there is a significant disconnect in the book, not just in the language the chapters are written in originally. Based on the disconnect in writing style and language used in the book it is hard to tell whether the book was intended as a whole or pieced together. It seems more logical that it would have been pieced together. I am still trying to figure out some logical or illogical reason to why there is a difference in the language and can only seem to think the chapters were composed independently of one another and combined at a later date. Or some poetic writing style where it breaks down like:
1-Hebrew
2-6-Aramaic
7-Aramaic
8-12-Hebrew
But I can't decide if that is me just looking and finding a pattern or if it was intentional. I'm not sure.

I think this is coherent.

Prophecy with a bit of ancient history

Reading prophecy is always something that I am very weary about, and even more so, those who attempt to take their interpretations as fact. There are so many ways of interpreting a single passage and it is for this reason the texts can be misused. One can make anything fit into prophecy. It is seen everyday with the writings of Nostradamus, and every other person who "predicted" the end of the world. Terrifying the population because an earthquake happened, or a war began at a certain time. In reading Richard Horsely's Revolt of the Scribes I was not taken back by his reading of the text but instead very interested in reading more. The mixture of history and interpretation allows for the reader an understanding that is deeper than if they just read it themselves. Not being a scholar of ancient history makes reading the bible difficult at times, so when I sat down to read Daniel I was able to take apart each of the chapters with Horsely's book right next to me.

The scare factor, that is used in many interpretations of apocalyptic texts is not seen as much in the interpretation of Horsely. Instead of having the end times be devastating, it is instead going to be a wonderful empire ruled by God. That is why all of the other empires need to fall so God can take control once again over what he created. When an empire such as that formed by Antiochus would eventually be taken down by God because it is only the right of God to rule in the highest. It is because of this that the scribes had to resist the ruling of these evil empires. It is interesting that Horsely looks so closely at how the resistance of the scribes and their martyrdom can take the place of the sacramental acts in the temple because the temple is not spoken of. The influence of Hellenistic society on the writing of this time by Jews is something to take note of as we spoke about in class.
Before discussing what I enjoyed most about Horsley's chapter on Daniel (comments which will generally reflect my feelings for his examination of the prophecy we have read so far), I would not my misgivings about his presentation. Horsley seems to take his method of understanding prophecy as the only possible correct understanding of Biblical interpretation. While I do feel that his method of analysis, proceeding from a literary-historical point of view, is the accurate one, statements such as the following seem to go beyond statements of argumentative certainty and move into the realm of intellectual arrogance: "In both Daniel 7 and 10-12, it is clear that this renewal of the people is not the end of the world or earthly life, but a restoration to an independent historical life under the rule of God" (102). But this isn't clear. In fact, it has taken him 20 pages to establish this as a plausible line of argument in particular, and the better part of an entire book for it to seem like a reasonable proposition in general.

However, I have found Horsley's work an extremely gratifying read. As opposed to the other secondary texts that I have been exposed to on Biblical interpretation, it does not rely too much on citation but rather on those key passages that are necessary in order for Horsley to make his point best. Moreover, Horsley presents a massive amount of information on a great deal of separate topics (a distinction which he problematizes, and I would agree correctly) succinctly without boring his reader or confusing him with an overabundance of historical curiosities.

As specifically relates to Daniel, what I found most interesting was his portrayal of the maskilim as caught in a tension about how to respond to their covenantal duties due to their position in society. While desiring to assist the Israelite population, these scribes lacked any social filiation with groups that mounted military or other forms of active revolt (in a sense which we might understand it today). So it seems that their conceptualization of how one revolts against imperial power is to attempt to impart "wisdom" on the very people that this learning is, by-and-large, denied by their own social practices. Due to the interrelation of religion and politics, this is not understood as an apolitical or passive act, much less an act which could not bear fruit for the Israelites suffering under oppression.

Mark of the Beast == Dark Mark?

After reading Kraybill (which I really enjoyed) I started thinking about the Mark of the Beast. I then realized that there are striking similarities between the Mark of the Beast and the Dark Mark of Voldemort from J.K. Rowlings' Harry Potter series. Although John and Mrs. Rowling are obviously trying to achieve different goals, both have similar understandings of evil and therefore a closer examination of similarities between the Dark Mark and the Mark of the Beast may help one to understand what John is trying to tell the reader through his use of the Mark of the Beast.

First of all, both marks are taken voluntarily. I find that quite interesting because both John of Patmos and J.K. Rowling create narratives where evil is not an accident. Even from reading the materials from your Old Testament class, evil is a choice. One does not accidentally serve Voldemort, Satan, or Canaanite gods. One chooses to do so. It seems to me that these conceptions of evil all stem from same view that evil acts are only intentional acts. This is comforting when looking at one's own society but grows problematic when one society's evil is another society's norm. If one is raised by a Deatheater and taught to serve Voldemort is that evil? If a child is born and raised in a society of emperor worship and they participate in said worship, is it evil? Kraybill does an excellent job of putting Revelation in its early Christian context but unfortunately that same context is limiting in that absolute evils (Nero) are hard to separate from those associated with evil ( regular Roman people). The Mark may be evil, but it is hard to say the same necessarily about those who wear it.

Like the Dark Mark, it is implied that the mark of the Beast never goes away. Like moral impurity in Leviticus, some evil cannot be reversed. This is frightening. Through His crucifixion, death, and resurrection, Jesus is said to be able to absolve us of our sins. Murderers and rapists and all other sorts of vile people can, in most Christian theology, be "saved." So for the Mark to not only be permanent physically but spiritually as well gives power to the Mark in a way that is foreign to almost anything else in the New Testament. Somehow the magic in the Dark Mark can never fully leave, as most former Deatheaters found out at Voldemort's return, and the evil of the Mark can somehow override the power of the death of God's son. Both marks, willingly accepted, contain evil that cannot ever be fully washed away.

In my mind, John of Patmos warned people of the Mark of the Beast, the mark of the Roman Empire, because he thought is was an irreversible and destructive evil that once accepted was impossible to escape from. Those killed by Voldemort were in a sense redeemed, saved, etc. by Love conquering dark magic. Voldemort however, could never be saved because he was the enemy of Love. Similarly, Christians killed for their faith by the Beast would be redeemed by Christ's love. The beast could never be saved by Christ because he enemy was Christ. John of Patmos presents the reader with an option: one can either take the mark of power in this life and forfeit spiritual redemption or reject the evils of the empire (Roman or otherwise) and risk bodily destruction but be guaranteed to be redeemed spiritually.


DunsonKA

Thursday, February 24, 2011

1 Enoch

When first reading the book of 1 Enoch I compared it to some Greek myths about the Titan Cronus having children with Mother Earth who then gives birth to the 100 Handed ones, Cyclopes, etcetera. These Giants in 1 Enoch share some similarities to the children of Cronus and Mother Earth because they tend to destroy things on the Earth and in both stories the Gods or God do something in their power to get rid of them so that the Earth can be at peace again. On another note when reading Horsley and the introduction by Nickelsburg/Vanderkam they tell us whom each character is supposed to refer to. For instance that the sheep who are lost and blind are the Jews and the white cows are Humans. I would like to know if in the Gospels when Jesus speaks of the Shepherd and the Sheep he is also referring to the sheep as the Jews or as anyone who is lost in their faith? A different point I would like to bring up is that of 1 Enoch really being an apocalyptic text or could we see it mainly as a political text. I feel that it is not as apocalyptic as we think it is but maybe that’s just me. Horsley says that the term “the day of tribulation” was a term also used for imperial oppression and the struggle against it in the hopes that God intervenes to save the day. He also says that in the text when it speaks of the Earth shaking and fire that it is referring to the awesome power of theophany. There is also another allusion to God as an Eagle who protects his young and takes them to a place of rest and nourishment. I thought this was interesting as well because this idea of God as an Eagle is found in the book of Exodus and Deuteronomy; which share some interesting allusions to God in all three texts.

Wednesday, February 23, 2011

As I read Daniel 1-6 last time, and now reading Enoch it is easy to see why these texts are usually lumped into the category of “apocalyptic literature”. Horsley with his arguments and historical data attempts to disprove that these texts hold any “apocalyptic” power in an eschatological sense. It has personally been a challenge to face these last couple of readings. I had not previously known of the existence of “other apocalyptic texts”, and now I’m faced with evidence to disprove that these texts should be categorized together in the first place. It is also slightly mind-warping to encounter a few scary parallels between “end of days” ideas to these readings, particularly to Nickelsburg and VanderKam. In the opening paragraphs of the Introduction to 1 Enoch by Nickelsburg and VanderKam they paraphrase a part of 1 Enoch that speaks of “a common world view that characterizes this present world and age as evil and unjust and in need of divine adjudication”(1). This present world and age? To me this faintly reverberates LaHaye and Jenkins’ ideology. Enoch himself (and many other writers, I have come to understand) write in such a manner that makes it easy for readers who are not studying texts in their historical context to become confused about their true meaning. Enoch sought for his work to be “made public in the last times to constitute the eschatological community of the chosen” (1). Even the word “chosen” reminds me of “those not left behind”. Enoch upholds the belief in a divine judgment that will come, after which “the third and final era of human history begins. God constructs a new Jerusalem, the Gentiles come to pay homage to the Jews. The dispersed people of God return, and the dead are raised.”(9) Maybe I must admit I have been traumatized by the end-of-days view of these types of texts, so much so that I am having a hard time distancing myself from that particular perspective, and opening up to Horsley’s writings. However I am grateful for Horsley’s book, which very clearly and with much detail explains major historical influences on Daniel and 1 Enoch.

Francis Bowen

1 Enoch tells the story of a generation of vicious giants, and their defeat by the heavenly army. In the Story, the giants "devoured the labor of humans and killed the humans until the whole earth cried out" (Horsley, 54). officers in the heavenly government brought the behavior of the giants to the "king of kings," who gave the order for the giants to be destroyed. Horsley goes one to describe human affairs as being, "affected, even determined, by heavenly forces."

This is strikingly similar in many ways to aspects of Greek mythology. In Greek Mythology there are references to giants and Heavenly forces, who control elements of human life ranging from famine and food production, to war and death. According to Horsley, George Nickelsburg claims that the defeat of the giants was symbolic of the battles that took place during the time of the Diadochoi. I am slightly confused by Horsley's denouncement of this statement. Horsley presents an argument against the metaphorical hypothesis by saying iron weapons had been around for nearly a millennium. This argument confuses me because it seems as if the giants and heavenly beings are symbolic, then wouldn't the gift of iron be as well?

Personally, I favor Horsleys second argument claiming that the story is largely a result of the "Hellenistic rule on the people of Judah" (Horsley, 57). This seems to satisfy many problems, at least to me. A Hellenistic influence would explain the similarities to Greco-Roman mythologies.

America-Tinted Glasses


I was kind of reality-checked by Horsley's reminders that most people, when they go to interpret texts like Daniel, are looking at them from an era when religion and government are [supposed to be] separate entities, and it can really color the way we read ancient texts. For example, a lot of people may interpret the examples of Daniel and his compatriots as proof that civic duty and religious observance can go hand in hand. While I’m sure that’s not a bad interpretation, I’m also not sure it’s what the author was trying to convey, especially when we consider the conundrum that the scribes were clearly placed in when their loyalties could only lie with one party – God, or their aristocratic patrons. It’s also a bit of a paradox when we consider the actual political/religious climate in which we live; the two are rarely truly separate and thus we often identify people with certain political affiliations based on religious thought and likewise the other way around. This perspective comes into play more and more as 1 Enoch outlines what Horsley describes as “crises” that must be explored in a way that takes into account the many nuances of the political climate at the time of the writings. The policies and culture of the dominant empire overseeing Judea at any given time had a huge impact on the ins and outs of Judean culture, whether acknowledged or not. In light of this knowledge, I felt better equipped to understand the subversive messages in Daniel and the messages of hope in 1 Enoch. While both texts make it clear that those who oppress the Judeans will eventually get what’s coming to them, they go further than that, boldly implying that the “chosen people” shouldn’t worry about their loyalties being divided, because their God will protect them from those who would have their allegiance above Him. I couldn’t help but be guilty of looking at this message through my twenty-first-century lenses and imagining what a dangerous one it might be, especially among those who might interpret it solely in terms of this era and use it as justification to defy law and governance on the grounds that they answer only to God. I’d be interested to know how many other Bible passages probably look different when you go deep into the socio-historical context and peel away centuries’ worth of Sunday-school-esque connotations such as those associated with “Daniel in the Lions’ Den.” I can’t help but think that most people would rather not have their kids learning the real message – “Only God is the boss of me!”

Is Kal-el a Watcher?

The people of Israel in the third century BCE (when scholars think Enoch was written) were having a tough time of it. Various empires had conquered them in the preceding years and the Diadochai were fighting over how to split up Alexander’s conquests. Horsley makes a good argument for understanding historical context when interpreting religious texts. Without historical context misinterpretation of any text, not just religious ones, can occur. Imagine people in the year 3000 reading “A Modest Proposal” and not knowing the context in which it was written.

At first glance Enoch seems like it would fit with “apocalyptic” texts. The wicked are destroyed, the world is cleansed and the righteous receive the blessings of heaven. Simply taken as is it is easy to see how Enoch could be classified as apocalyptic, but when it is read with the historical context in mind the Book of Watchers takes on a different meaning. The scribes in this time period have a problem if they believe that they are righteous protecters of their tradition and that imperial rule is a punishment from God. By explaining the violence with rebel watchers and a remote God with a heavenly bureaucracy this issue is resolved. The scribes would have been reassured by the idea that God was not punishing them, but was ultimately still in control and would eventually intervene. Although I don’t really find the idea of a god so out of touch with the world that he has to be made aware of problems and then not take care of them himself that great either. I think this give the scribes a motivation for writing the Book of Watchers. If, according to Horsley’s argument, this idea was reassuring to people living through imperial rule in the third century BCE it would be more likely to be written down and shared with others.


I think reading within the historical context is a good idea and I liked Horsley’s interpretation of the Book of Watchers as an explanation of imperial violence and a reassurance that God was still in control. I think the historical argument Horsley makes is a simpler and more believable argument than saying that the Book of Watchers is apocalyptic prophecy. I’m sure that we will get to look at Revelation from a historical perspective in the future and I think that will be a more logical interpretation for me than rapture theology and apocalypticism.



Revolt of the Scribes

I really have enjoyed this book because it tells about the historical events that were occurring during the writing of the different apocalyptic. Though it does tend to sound much like a history textbook, I still think the perspective the authors offer is a very valid point people should hear. From the religious studies courses I've taken at Hendrix, I've learned that this historical perspective of the Bible is extremely important; I'm glad to take a break from seemingly over-the-top predictions and learn the background of these texts.

I also found it interesting that the scribes of the Enoch texts could have been protesting the changes that the Second Temple leaders were making to reform the church and make it hellenized. We've heard that the authors of apocalyptic texts often wrote in code about destroying the royal empires, but instead in these sections, they're protesting their fellow believers. It does remind me of how Evangelicals look down on other sects of Christianity are not following what God "really" wanted.

I think it's comforting that the Enoch texts don't predict a "catastrophe of cosmic proportions," when God come's to judge the people. So often in today's view, that same time period is portrayed as a horrifically violent time and is used by Evangelicals as a scare tactic to convert others. It's also coincides with the common view that God is a loving, caring, generous God more than the wrathful and jealous God of Revelation.

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

The radical call in "apocalyptic" texts

The political dimensions of the "apocalyptic" tales are important, and something that is particularly invigorating for groups whose ideological tendencies are being suppressed by the overall society. These apocalyptic texts were written at a time when "Judaism" was being replaced by "Hellenism." These scribes believed "their authority came directly from the Most High, the giver of the Torah." However, this "left them caught in the middle, in conflict between their loyalty to the aristocracy on whom they were economically dependent and their commitment to the covenant commandments." This is something that I have always had trouble with religious and Christian doctrine, since in order to function in a society one has to fund and even give to corrupt people. If a Christian teaching is to promote nonviolence and "to love thy neighbor," then why do I pay taxes that fund wars that I am morally against? The true Christian call and message is radical, and very often not lived out fully, we are far from the "New Jerusalem" that Revelations describes. I think that "apocalyptic" texts do not function as merely "opposition to imperial rule," but a radical call to oppose corruption and hierarchical rule in any form, even one is thrown in the "fiery furnaces." Power is corruptible and generally evil, as exemplified in Daniel. No ruler is ever completely good, despite Nebuchadnezzar recognizing the power of Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego, he is not able to understand fully God’s message until he is transformed into a lowly animal like creature who is “made to eat grass like oxen.” Only after this period is reason able to return to him. The apocalyptic texts not only represent opposition towards power, but also the hard and often radical change that has to happen in order for the "New Jerusalem" to come.

Monday, February 21, 2011

Upon beginning Revolt of the Scribes, I was a little frustrated because the book read so much like a history book. I feel like the Introduction and the first chapter lack accessibility, particularly for those without a strong background in ancient history or religion. With that being said, I really appreciate Horsley’s attempt to place various religious texts into a historical background; this is particularly refreshing due to the nature of the rapture theology we have recently be discussing.

Thus far, I like Horsley’s argument that many biblical scholars simply talk about the book of Daniel in terms of “religious persecution,” which is a misinterpretation of the actual historical context in which Daniel was written. Form Horsley’s account, the situation of the people in Jerusalem, particularly the scribes, was not one of religious persecution, but rather a situation of tension between adherence to religious beliefs and political code. This establishes Daniel, as well as other religious texts, as a political document instead of something that was simply divinely inspired.

By regarding Daniel as a political commentary, Horsley examines a facet of the text that could easily be overlooked in the context of its “prophetic” messages. I have personally long believed that most religious texts, whether ancient or modern, have a political agenda. Both religion and politics are vehicles to promote specific belief systems or if not promote the belief itself, promote change which is in harmony with the said belief. In this way it is unsurprising that religion and politics can often be found either in unity or in direct opposition.

I think that Horsley elegantly demonstrates the ability of religion and politics to commingle. Furthermore, his argument is not only relevant to Daniel and other apocalyptic texts, but to the evangelical movement in our own country. In particular, the religious and political vehicle that is “rapture theology.”

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Rapture Theology (1830 B.C.)

I found segments of Barbara R. Rossing's view on Revelation and the Bible as a whole quite intriguing and compelling. One stance that Rossing takes that really appealed to me was that the Bible still has the same message today as it did to its original 1st centurey readers: that Jesus, not the Antichrist, nor Caesar, nor any president is the true leader of the world. I felt like she did an adequate job of explaining her case throughout the book. My favorite way she undermined rapture theology was by emphasizing the fact that it was invented about 170 years ago. I found this to be an extremely effective rebuttal to LaHaye's and Jenkin's argument due to its seeming impossibility of having any relevance to the era when Revelation was written. She simply illustrates that if this theology was created just 170 years ago then that means the writer could not possibly have had the intent of prophesying a "rapture".

LaHaye and Jenkins might tippy toe their way around her rebuttal by referring to the Bible as being the "living word" of God; hence it changes in time. Although they might be able to reason this, I believe the meaning of the "living word of God" is completely different in a sense. I believe that it is fully relevant today as ever and that the Word of life is alive among us through the Holy Spirit. Therefore, I like how Rossing in a way implies that Scripture does not need any kind of updating, editing, or refining.

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Christian Escape Artists

I see quiet an interesting similarity between dispensational theology and the beliefs of the early sect of Christianity of Gnosticism. There were many more wildly different forms of Christianity during the first and second century than today. The Gnostics believed that the words of Jesus provided some secret, mythical code which, if discovered, would provide enlightenment or salvation. Gnostics believed that some divine spark was trapped in them and this secret knowledge allowed their true self to escape Earth to return to the realm of God, or as many Gnostics believed, the gods. These early escapists searched for some hidden knowledge just as dispensationalists are doing today.

Dispensationalists claim to have found this hidden knowledge that will allow escape from Earth. What causes this commonality of Gnostics and dispensationalists? Why do they believe that God wants to abandon the Earth he created and take them with him? Why do they want God to destroy his creation? Perhaps these are questions that cannot be answered.

As Rossing points out numerous times, God wants to be in the world with us and all his creation. Dispensationalists need to see this beautiful piece of hope and stop trying to escape from this world.

Rossing's Group Questions

Although I originally scoffed at the Reader Discussion Guide at the end of The Rapture Exposed, some of Rossing's questions are farily insightful and I wanted to discuss them for my blog. Let's begin!

#1. "Rossing contends that Rapture theology 'distorts God's vision for the world.' What is your understanding of the vision of God for humankind and the earth? . . ."

I think that this question, knowingly or unknowingly, gets at a really interesting point which is that somone's understanding of God's vision for humankind (especially the end of humankind) is always something that that particular person finds appealing. Liberal, progressive Christians never say "well, I really hoped that God was all about multi-culturalism but now I know he only likes Republicans" and Conservative Rapture Theology Evangelicals never say "I really wish the Rapture would have happened and I am surprised at the number of gay people with me in heaven." This is a complicated way of saying that anyone's vision of God's plan is always a better reflection of their personal beliefs than in any plan God may or may not have.

On that note, I don't think God has a plan. He started the cosmos churning, may or may not have been tied to Jesus showing up (if Jesus was divine), and other than that may not be doing anything or have any plan. (think Aristotle's unmoved mover or Clockwork Deism.


#40 . . . How do you respond to the idea that the world cannot be saved?

My response is to ignore it. Listening to people who have no faith in humanity is time that could be spent doing good works and sharing the love that Christ exemplified. The verb save in Rapture Theology seems to be an event where God does most of the work (that is saving someone). When I think of the word save, I think of people doing the work. Why wait for God to take care of everything(which I doubt he will) when I am in possesion of perfectly functioning agency right now?


Finally,
#44. How often do you think about the end of the world?

Well, since I am in this class, quite a bit. However I distinctly differentiate the end of the world with the end of everything. Even if the world was to end ( due to a catastrophe, not 4 horsemen) the story of existence is not over. Rapture Theology is not only dangerous because it is not concerned about the future state of the world (ex: environmental issues) but also because Rapture Theolgy eliminates the rest of the cosmos of having any importance. Abraham was to have more descendants than the stars in the sky and we, people of Earth, are just one planet orbiting one star. If God exists, he does not exist only in Churches, America, the Western World, or our planet but rather across time and space (literally). Our God is an awesome God and his dominion is over HEAVEN and Earth. Let us not forget that heaven is not only the residence of the Church Triumphant but also the cosmos in its entirety.

K Dunson
What I found most interesting about Barbara Rossing's account was her exposition of the dispensationalist method of interpretation which underlies Rapture theology. A creation of John Nelson Darby, dispensationalism (according to Rossing) attempts to map a coherent Biblical narrative onto world-historical occurrences, and to explain world events in terms of prophecy. This method, argues Rossing, necessarily forces gaps into prophetic passages in order that they maintain coherence with the overall narrative Rapture theologians wish to tell. That narrative is based on Daniel 9:25-27, giving a chronology of 70 weeks of Israel's history. However, even this prophetic passage must be broken up. The reasoning for this, Rossing argues, is arbitrary.

The reason I wish to have this all on the page is to draw attention to Rossing's mode of complicating the idea of a "literal" interpretation of the Bible. Highlighting the fact that Darby's dispensationalism underlies the Rapture theology of LaHaye Et al. makes such a claim possible only in ignorance of historical realities about one's own position. Moreover, when one approaches the supposedly "literal" reading with a view to the mode of interpretation which produced such a reading, it becomes readily apparent that such a reading is much more heavily indebted to "creative interpretation" than a reading of Biblical text on its own terms through those lenses which pay careful attention to historical cues and symbolic devices.

The question I am left with is: what would be the most effective device in opposing the approach of Rapture theology? In my estimation, Rapture theology is, for all intents and purposes, the equivalent of any other culture commodity spun out by an advanced capitalist society where commercialism has replaced industrialism. That the popularity of such a theology is made popular by a preponderance of television preachers and fiction authors is a ready indication of this. It does not seem to me that opposing a more sophisticated theology is necessarily the best countermeasure against the devastating effects of the LaHaye doctrine, for the simple reason that it does not sell as well.

"For God so loved the world that he sent World War III?"

Unsurprisingly, I found Barbara Rossing’s chapter entitled “The Rapture Script for the Middle East,” particularly interesting and unsettling. From Americans attempting to breed a pure red heifer so that Jews may enter the rebuilt temple to the fact that an enormous portion of end-time prophecy is based on three verses in Daniel, neither we as disheartening and upsetting as the current role of prophecy in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

It is highly shocking that so many Christians would want to promote the continuation of these conflicts. Christian Zionists are directly contributing to the occupation of the West Bank, which has resulted in extensive violence from Israeli soldiers and displaced Palestinians. It is strange to me, because even if I believed in the imminent return of Christ and the Tribulation, which would precede him, I cannot imagine actually hoping for the violence that would lead to this point in history.

On some level, I am compelled to ask, though Jesus’ return to earth would be desirable, does it actually outweigh the death and destruction that may ensue? Furthermore, how is it that these Christian Zionists believe that supporting Israeli Jews (who evidently will not be saved from this violence unless sometime during the Tribulation they accept Christ) to promote their own personal rapture is more pleasing than supporting Palestinian Christians? Many of these people adhere to the same evangelical teachings, so why would they be left out of the equation of the end-times, or at best be playing an “introductory” role to the end-times, if they believe in the same God and Christ? Is it because they aren’t white, or because they aren’t American?

Rossing does an excellent job of punching even more holes in the extremist, end-time prophecy belief system and manages to make me even angrier with these people. Fortunately, she manages to encourage me as well. By discussing those Israelites and Palestinians who are hoping to work towards peace rather than violence, she reminds me that there are people who want to end these conflicts despite differences in their belief systems. That is an idea I can resonate with; for me, suggesting violence must occur for Jesus to perform an ultimate act of love, returning to earth, is nonsensical, but to suggest that when we achieve peace he will return is encouraging and uplifting.


Sorry to everyone if this is incoherent, these folks just make me so mad I can't think straight.

"The Bible itself has been left behind"


Throughout The Rapture Exposed, Barbara Rossing makes the point to contrast Biblical concepts with the theology connected to dispensationalist and the Rapture. I found it particularly interesting given the fact that dispensationalists above all claim a strictly literal interpretation of scripture.

One example of this that she utilizes often is the contrasts between the images of a loving and self-giving Jesus to the violent escapism that seems inseparable from Tribulation theology, at least in practice. In particular, I was drawn to a passage on page 35 when Rossing states that, “Christians are not dealt a get-out-of-tribulation-free card to play in the face of the world’s suffering and trials […] Jesus never asked of God to “beam me up” from the Earth, nor can we […] God saves us not by snatching us out of this world, but by coming into the world to be with us” (35). It seems to me almost an insult to the idea of a creator God to claim that what he created is so flawed as to be irredeemable. Certainly if that were the case, according to Christian theology, God would not have sent his son to the Earth to suffer with man and die for man’s sins.  I think another good quote from the book that falls under this same idea is the title of a particular section: “God so loved the world that he sent World War Three” (Rossing 42).

Rossing also points out some of the ridiculous contradictions involved in calling Rapture Theology literal, strict Biblicism. She points out that various points of dispensationalist theology that claim strict biblical origins are, in fact, twisted manipulations of miniscule bits of scripture. She discusses the claims of the seven years of tribulation, for example- tribulation is a term she never discovers in the Bible, and the seven years of it derives from a verse in David that talks of seven days of suffering.

I enjoyed reading this book because it gave me the Biblically-backed rebuttals to the theology of LaHaye, Jenkins, et al that I felt existed but could not point a finger to due to my lack of Biblical studies.

Ethics Over Prediction

The message to Matthew's original readers was the same as the message today: Whatever traumas befall us, we are to be urgent in loving our neighbor, urgent in caring for the world that God created, urgent in feeding the hungry and visiting prisoners, urgent in living faithfully as Christ commanded us to live.- p. 181

Throughout Are We Living in the End Times, I kept getting caught up on the ethics of the whole idea of the Rapture: Christians, who have been called to love and care for all of God's children, will be taken away from the earth during it's most dire time and watch with God while all of their families, friends, and everyone else who isn't a "real" Christian suffer as the world is in turmoil and destruction. How can this be in line with anything else the bible says? On page 13 of The Rapture Exposed, Rossing discusses the difference in the social gospel movement and rapture theology which emphasized the goal "not to make the world better, but to save people out of the world." I have always valued the community that comes with Christianity, the focus of the church centered on helping others and sharing God's love, but rapture theology creates a self-centered Christianity that is not coherent with anything Jesus teaches in the Gospels. Not only does this theology destroy the important aspect of communal living in Christianity but it makes the world seem like a dump truck waiting to be filled up and taken to the junkyard. Unlike Anne Coulter's view ("God gave us the earth. We have dominion over the plants, the animals, the trees. God said, 'Earth is yours. Take it. Rape it. It's yours.'"), Panentheism, the idea that God exists and is an interwoven part of each aspect of nature supports the ethics of nurturing the earth since God is in the earth as he is in each of us. I appreciated that Rossing expressed her concern with the ethics of rapture theology, and I think that her idea of Jesus' second coming, as stated in the preface that"God is coming to heal the world, not to kill millions of people", leaves us with a much better outlook on the book of Revelation.

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

The Rapture Exposed

Although I do miss all the amazing charts and clocks that LaHaye and Jenkins have in their book I really enjoyed reading The Rapture Exposed. Rossing from the beginning gives her readers proper citations and quotes from real people who know how to read the bible and interpret it; not only does she do this but she also gives her readers an opportunity to read different quotes from different people who all have different opinions on the rapture and its meaning.

On page 36 she quotes LaHaye when he said, “the Bible devotes more space to the seven year tribulation than to any other historical period.” She and I both disagree; what about Jesus’ life and teachings or the Exodus from Egypt? The bible clearly devotes way more space to Jesus’ life and teachings than to something that to LaHaye hasn’t even happened yet. Not only that but this seven-year tribulation that LaHaye talks about is not even plainly in the bible, it’s something that dispensationalists try to find in different meanings or different excerpts from the bible. Dispensationalists’ use of excerpts from the bible does not help their cause either because by reading excerpts and snippets of different passages in the bible we in turn read it out of context.

With that being said Rossing, towards the end of the book, lets us look at the three prominent excerpts that dispensationalists love to look at when claiming the rapture in 1 Thessalonians, Matthew and John. I liked that she did this because she showed us them from their historical views and why they were written for their historical audiences; she did not take them out of context and piece them together with other parts of the bible like dispensationalists love to do. In the Matthew excerpt she also states that his meaning could have been purposely ambiguous because the focus should be for us and his intended audience to be ready for Jesus and for us to live a Christian life.

I also agree with her argument on page 73 that Christianity, Islam and Judaism are all religions of peace and that each of them has a violent sect of believers who are extremists; but we cannot support them because it will lead to terrible consequences for us all. Rossing also makes a good point when she points out that LaHaye and Jenkins attract audiences with violence and war because its exhilirating for people and to dispensationalists it gives them what they think are clear cut answers.