Monday, April 4, 2011

Reasons for pushing away Revelation and the Glorification of the United States

In the article “Revelation: Clarity and Ambivalence, A Hispanic/ Cuban American Perspective,” by Justo Gonzalez, I found myself very drawn in by his introduction. In fact, Gonzalez expresses many of the same feelings and interpretations I experienced growing up. He also made me realize that my feelings (that of an American girl) were not so different than his (a Cuban American male.) Gonzalez makes several points I agree and relate to, the first being his mention of the way his protestant churches, in particular the Methodist church, very seldom references or discuss the book of Revelation. Having also grown up in a Methodist Church, I can personally attest to the fact that the book of Revelation was rarely mentioned. Gonzalez quote perfectly sums up my experience, “ It is not surprising that we tended to shy away from the book of Revelation, with its weird visions, multi-headed monsters, and words of woe” (Gonzalez,48). I realized when reading this introduction that it seems as though the people who preach “the coming of the great tribulation” tend to scare people away from the book, and therefore its original message. I also realized that this is true not only in the United States, but in other countries as well. Sadly this leads people to just ignore the book or Revelation all together, andfor many people it leads us to classify the people who claim to know the exact date of the rapture, orwhat or who the actual beast, as crazy people not worth our time. Gonzalez also makes a very good point, in my opinion, when he mentions the glorification of America. During the Cold War, Gonzalez make a point to stress that many people thought of the Soviet Union as the “Evil Empire, “ and were thankful for its collapse. This lead people to take on the belief that the United States could “do no evil, and that therefore any who resisted or criticized it, from Osama bin Laden to Jacques Chirac, were evil” (Gonzalez, 48). I have never really thought of this before, but now that I have read this article it makes perfect sense.

I found Justo Gonzalez’s arguments about similar situations and culture in his essay “Revelation: Clarity and Ambivalence” to be strange. He breaks his argument for seeing parallels between our culture and John of Patmos’s culture down into three parts: geopolitical, economic and cross cultural.

In the geopolitical section he compares criticism of Rome in John’s context, which is basically treason, to criticism of the United States being seen as supporting communism in the second half of the 20th century. Gonzalez says that John’s call for resisting the Roman lifestyle which fell short of the geopolitical order in new Jerusalem can be extended to any world order. Of course the United States is imperfect; but I do not think, in the grand scheme of things, its government has that much in common with an ancient empire that executed people based on cultural differences. I am a little more comfortable with comparing the economic order. Its easier for me to see the comparison between Roman gluttony and Western materialism.

In his last section Gonzalez says that empire’s have greater cultural exchanges and thus more conflict. He claims that the ancient Roman emperor’s fears of Christianity based on their fears of superstitions and that it was corrupting the culture is similar to how some Americans fear immigrants. While it is true that there is xenophobia in America, many issues that people have with immigrants today are so different from Rome’s superstitious fears. People worry about jobs and taxes in addition to xenophobia. I found it interesting that he claims that even John is upset by the Jewish culture loosing its privileged place with God in new Jerusalem. New Jerusalem does away with culture because everyone is equal to God. However, I can see his final point that we do not resist troublesome issues in our culture because we benefit from the system.

And as if I needed another reason to distrust the apocalyptic end time readings of Revelation popular in the United States, Gonzalez very successfully states further problems with these interpretations. He states that to turn Revelation into a program for the end of days is not only to disregard the context in which Revelation was written, but it ignores the fact that these interpretations would render John’s narrative useless for those Jewish Christians of the ancient world. They would only know that in some very distant future, God would avenge their sufferings, but for now, there would be no answer.

Gonzalez seems to suggest that Revelation, while it may be respected for historical context and meaning for ancient Christians, it has value for contemporary Christians as well and that for neither was Revelation meant to function as a prediction of future events. Revelation is a book that may offer hope to any Christians, caught in a struggle between their faith and the “empire” within which they live. As Gonzalez said, we read the Bible to understand how God relates to his people, and we should do no differently with Revelation.

Once again, I feel hopeful reading essays that explain Revelation in this light because they emphasize the value of Revelation, as well as the rest of the Bible, in ways that even adherents of other religions and people from varying backgrounds may relate to the message of God. Especially important is that this is what God’s message is supposed to be: something that reaches out and takes hold of many, not just the few. His message is for John’s followers as well as people who are just beginning to turn towards God.

The Power of the Present

John of Patmos calls for us to oppose Babylon at any cost. However, in reality, if we see that Babylon represents something that still exists, often we can reflect that we still have investments in the “Babylonian” system. What makes the book confusing today is that while in some ways we as Christians are oppressed today, we are also often part of the oppression. The book of Revelation , as Gonzalez argues, is too clear, we are not ambivalent about Revelation. Instead, we are “ambivalent about our discipleship because we are quite comfortable in the present order – and yet claim to yearn for another.” What fascinates me about these particular authors is that they are often very cognizant of this, they are academics that have been blessed with accomplishment, yet still have elements of oppression in their past and even their present lives. This is what makes Revelation complex, when are you the oppressor serving Babylon, or when are you working towards a New Jerusalem? It would seem that few are living what John of Patmos is calling for because of the comfort of our own lives. By seeing these intercultural perspectives, we can see how to oppose some of the beastly powers, but not all. The hard thing to accept about Revelation is the realization that you might be part of the beastly system and not even recognize it. In our society, we still have a lot of work to get to the New Jerusalem, and there are some aspects of our lives that will in future years be considered immensely beast-like. It amazes us, as Americans, to see how long we allowed slavery. However, maybe in future years Americans will be surprised that our taxes were used to pay for wars, and future generations will lament that it took so long to get that horrible act erased. I think that, instead of focusing on past events, we should instead focus on the present also.

Witnessing: Active or Passive?


While reading Brian Blount’s article “The Witness of Active Resistance” in the book From Every People and Nation, I was interested in his concept of ‘witnessing’ as the prescription John of Patmos provides for resisting the evil Roman Empire. He defines this as witnessing, or understanding, “the truth that was born by Jesus Christ” (Blount 38). This means that one must live her life according to the principles of Jesus and not allow anything, especially the allure of the Roman Empire, to come between her and her belief in Jesus.

I was interested in two points of this topic. One, Blount describes this witnessing as active. I do not see it as active. I see it as a refusal to participate in Empire idol worship, but that is passive resistance, not active.

I do not believe that I ever encounter a place in Blount’s essay that describes witnessing in an active way. He writes of people who have died due to their witnessing and wait patiently in heaven for God to enact justice on their behalf: “their passive waiting in heaven does not imply that they waited passively on earth. They are slaughtered souls in heaven precisely because they had actively witnessed to the testimony that Jesus is the ultimate Lord of human history in a world where Rome laid vicious claim to its own witness of ultimate authority” (Blount 41).

But what does this entail? What was this active witnessing that led to their deaths? Or was it an understanding of the power of God even over the Roman Empire and their gods? I still see this as passive. I think that Blount’s point is an interesting one, and one that I would not question if he could prove his claim that witnessing somehow involves active, not passive, resistance.
I found the selection of articles from "From Every People and Nation," edited by David Rhoads, to be relevant to my questions so far regarding how exactly one appropriates a historically located text as a source for ethical action. Rhoads, in the introduction, states that cultural interpretation proceeds from differentiation and engagement. By understanding the differences which mark ones contemporary cultural location from that of John's, one can proceed to "construct scenarios of meaning for Revelation in John's time" by engaging that text through one's own cultural location. The text can then be appropriated for contemporary life on the basis of many factors, better or worse, out of one's own cultural location. Respect for the text and ethical concerns are key here. One must be informed by intercultural engagement in considering the effects of interpretation and the power dynamics at play in any such interpretive process.

This being the case, the selections from the text assigned for this class session showcase a variety of ways in which to appropriate the text for contemporary life. Gonzalez argues that the patterns in history allow for comparison and thus to draw guidance from moments that parallel our own. This I find to fall within the same problematic constraints of Kraybill's method, so I won't really go into it.

Maier seems to argue that we occupy a history where Revelation, and offshoots of certain lines of thought or metaphors stemming from this book, where it has come to take a central place in justifying practices which run against another way of reading the text. In sum, it (or manifestations of utopianism and apocalypticism) has come to rationalize practices of civic religion and imperialism. Another reading of the text, which Maier thinks is the one conforming to the ethical one and the one of John's own location, is to understand resistance through the de-occupation of the social roles that empire designates for us. Although I find this argument compelling, I don't follow that Revelation plays as special a role in the overall development of civic religion and modern empirialism as he seems to think it does. Rather, it seems more that his best arguments concern a way to talk about taking oneself up in resistance to domination in terms of what Foucault might call "de-subjectivation," and presents Revelation as an example of a text which demonstrates a call for such a practice. However, I would again suggest that his concern that Revelation occupies a special place in understanding domination is more of a personal idiosyncrasy than evidence of a socio-cultural phenomena.

Finally, Blount understands revelation through a methodology of "meaning potential." That is, the text has no single meaning. Rather, a meaning can be brought out of the text, appropriated for specific concerns in relation to the themes presented. This "meaning potential" does not slide into subjectivist interpretation because the themes presented do have specific referents and thus can only mean certain things. Thus, Blount presents the case that Revelation's context is key to understanding the "meaning potential"--namely, that it is a text constructed by those in "situations 'from below.'" The text can be applied to cases of domination or oppression because of the context in which the text was produced, and because it was the context in response to which that text was reproduced. This way of appropriating Revelation, through taking seriously the contingency of its historical production while attentive to a coherent and strong message contained within the text, I find to be the most productive for a contemporary ethico-political project formed on its basis. However, I tend to agree more with Maier in terms of what that might look like.

Revelation: A Roman Perspective

If multiculturalism means everyone gets a voice then the Roman counter argument cannot be denied. A Roman Rebuttal by the trader and merchant Kentalus Maximus: John! My friend, you are too serious! These visions of yours sound unhealthy. Do you have some affliction of the head or maybe eat something tainted? Whatever the case, I can see that you are worried and who wouldn't be with dragons and destroyed cities floating through one's thoughts? I worry about you. I have traveled across the Mediterranean many times and I know a bit about you Jews. Maybe I can ease your pain. A friend of mine in Acre tells me this story about Jesus and his miracles. If these stories are true, Jesus has been granted power by the Gods indeed. Not only that, but his devotedness to rightouesness reminds me of the heros I grew up with. In fact, these stories about Jesus have very many similarities. Either Zeus or YHWH seems to keep enacting the same story! I appologize, I forget sometimes that the Pantheon offends your sensibilities. Anyway, I read your book and I am insulted! I live in the city of ten hills and I understand your language; I believe you misunderstand Rome. First of all, I take offense to the idea of this beautiful bastion of civilization in which I live being called a whore. A whore!? Strong words, my friend, strong words indeed. Rome and I serve each other and I do not feel dirtier from this collaboration. Has Rome had its share of flaws? My friend, I lived through Nero so I know she is not perfect. But Rome is greater than any one man. All peoples, including yourself, make up the glory of Rome. So when I travel across the seas and trade with upstanding men of different cultures, are we whoring too? When I return home from my voyage with a heavier purse to pay for my son's education and to provide a happy life for my daughters and wife is this evil? Is it evil to pay the men who work my ships so that they can provide for their own families? Whoever created man created all of the good things as well so why is a good meal in a nice house that I worked for so evil? What makes suffering better than laughter? Next, you complain about worshipping the emperor. Do you not remember what I said? Rome is all Romans, all people in the empire. The emperor can be wise or a lunatic but he is just one member of the body of Rome. So when I worship the Emperor, let us say it is Nero, I tell myself "this man is a lunatic but this lunatic keeps peoples livlihoods across the empire going so I will give him a nod." When a wise emperor rules, my worship is merely giving him the respect he is due. I do not concern myself with his divinity but rather with my family's happiness. At best, thanks goes to a good ruler and at worst I tell a lie. As far as my own religious beliefs, I consider them private and I find no reason to ruin good business with religion. You say my city is a whore but what do you have to offer? All I see is jealousy. You and your fellow members of this new sect are growing from what my contacts in the region are telling me. But, you still have no power. Power that Rome has. Furthermore, many of your believers are fools. If a lie can save a man's life then tell it! What is more rigteous in your eyes; telling the truth and being killed living one's family in poverty or telling a lie and allowing your children to grow up in a house rather than on the street. You tell me Babylon is a whore. Well, what is more self-serving; a self-rigthteous death that hurts those around you or a sacrifice of your pride to tell one lie and save the lives of all of those who rely on you. If Rome is a whore than you people are obsessed with self-pleasure. Finally, you speak of a new empire that will outshine Rome. Will you do this or will your God do this? I doubt your God, or my God, since I have yet to see him throw lightining at a blasphemer in my life time, does much of anything in this world. So then your only option for empire is through your own agency. Will Rome fall? Maybe, but not today or tomorrow. I doubt Rome will ever fall in a day. Only time will tell. Nevertheless, who will run your empire. It seems you believe that Jesus will come back from the dead to rule. So long as he does not bring back Nero I do not care (human torches are bad for business). So if Jesus rules this new empire, will he not need bureacrats? And will these bureacrats not be like you and I, mere men? Men can do great things. Look at the beauty of Rome or even the magnificence of your temple which I saw in my youth. But men can also do great evil. I have Nero and others to account for but what men will do evil in the name of your beliefs? I have always liked the Jews but if I was to say an empire run by them would be blameless I would be lying. Rome may fall and your empire may rise but she will not be perfect either. Your visions have caused you great pain and your advice to others will only make them uneccesarily suffer. You and these other Jews among you may believe whatever you want in your head and your own house. One nod and a leg of lamb is all you need to be a Christian and be able to enjoy your life. Babylon can provide for you in ways that God will not. Think of your family and those whom you love. You may serve God in your own ways and prosper through the glory of Rome. I beg you, for your sake, reconsider your vision.