This is the blog of the "Revelation and Resistance" course at Hendrix College. Your comments are welcomed and invited.
Monday, April 4, 2011
Reasons for pushing away Revelation and the Glorification of the United States
I found Justo Gonzalez’s arguments about similar situations and culture in his essay “Revelation: Clarity and Ambivalence” to be strange. He breaks his argument for seeing parallels between our culture and John of Patmos’s culture down into three parts: geopolitical, economic and cross cultural.
In the geopolitical section he compares criticism of Rome in John’s context, which is basically treason, to criticism of the United States being seen as supporting communism in the second half of the 20th century. Gonzalez says that John’s call for resisting the Roman lifestyle which fell short of the geopolitical order in new Jerusalem can be extended to any world order. Of course the United States is imperfect; but I do not think, in the grand scheme of things, its government has that much in common with an ancient empire that executed people based on cultural differences. I am a little more comfortable with comparing the economic order. Its easier for me to see the comparison between Roman gluttony and Western materialism.
In his last section Gonzalez says that empire’s have greater cultural exchanges and thus more conflict. He claims that the ancient Roman emperor’s fears of Christianity based on their fears of superstitions and that it was corrupting the culture is similar to how some Americans fear immigrants. While it is true that there is xenophobia in America, many issues that people have with immigrants today are so different from Rome’s superstitious fears. People worry about jobs and taxes in addition to xenophobia. I found it interesting that he claims that even John is upset by the Jewish culture loosing its privileged place with God in new Jerusalem. New Jerusalem does away with culture because everyone is equal to God. However, I can see his final point that we do not resist troublesome issues in our culture because we benefit from the system.
And as if I needed another reason to distrust the apocalyptic end time readings of Revelation popular in the United States, Gonzalez very successfully states further problems with these interpretations. He states that to turn Revelation into a program for the end of days is not only to disregard the context in which Revelation was written, but it ignores the fact that these interpretations would render John’s narrative useless for those Jewish Christians of the ancient world. They would only know that in some very distant future, God would avenge their sufferings, but for now, there would be no answer.
Gonzalez seems to suggest that Revelation, while it may be respected for historical context and meaning for ancient Christians, it has value for contemporary Christians as well and that for neither was Revelation meant to function as a prediction of future events. Revelation is a book that may offer hope to any Christians, caught in a struggle between their faith and the “empire” within which they live. As Gonzalez said, we read the Bible to understand how God relates to his people, and we should do no differently with Revelation.
Once again, I feel hopeful reading essays that explain Revelation in this light because they emphasize the value of Revelation, as well as the rest of the Bible, in ways that even adherents of other religions and people from varying backgrounds may relate to the message of God. Especially important is that this is what God’s message is supposed to be: something that reaches out and takes hold of many, not just the few. His message is for John’s followers as well as people who are just beginning to turn towards God.
The Power of the Present
Witnessing: Active or Passive?
This being the case, the selections from the text assigned for this class session showcase a variety of ways in which to appropriate the text for contemporary life. Gonzalez argues that the patterns in history allow for comparison and thus to draw guidance from moments that parallel our own. This I find to fall within the same problematic constraints of Kraybill's method, so I won't really go into it.
Maier seems to argue that we occupy a history where Revelation, and offshoots of certain lines of thought or metaphors stemming from this book, where it has come to take a central place in justifying practices which run against another way of reading the text. In sum, it (or manifestations of utopianism and apocalypticism) has come to rationalize practices of civic religion and imperialism. Another reading of the text, which Maier thinks is the one conforming to the ethical one and the one of John's own location, is to understand resistance through the de-occupation of the social roles that empire designates for us. Although I find this argument compelling, I don't follow that Revelation plays as special a role in the overall development of civic religion and modern empirialism as he seems to think it does. Rather, it seems more that his best arguments concern a way to talk about taking oneself up in resistance to domination in terms of what Foucault might call "de-subjectivation," and presents Revelation as an example of a text which demonstrates a call for such a practice. However, I would again suggest that his concern that Revelation occupies a special place in understanding domination is more of a personal idiosyncrasy than evidence of a socio-cultural phenomena.
Finally, Blount understands revelation through a methodology of "meaning potential." That is, the text has no single meaning. Rather, a meaning can be brought out of the text, appropriated for specific concerns in relation to the themes presented. This "meaning potential" does not slide into subjectivist interpretation because the themes presented do have specific referents and thus can only mean certain things. Thus, Blount presents the case that Revelation's context is key to understanding the "meaning potential"--namely, that it is a text constructed by those in "situations 'from below.'" The text can be applied to cases of domination or oppression because of the context in which the text was produced, and because it was the context in response to which that text was reproduced. This way of appropriating Revelation, through taking seriously the contingency of its historical production while attentive to a coherent and strong message contained within the text, I find to be the most productive for a contemporary ethico-political project formed on its basis. However, I tend to agree more with Maier in terms of what that might look like.