Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Active Endurance

The essay by James Chukwuma Okoye takes the perspective of an African reading the book of Revelation in which he addresses problems that many Africans have with the text and highlights a few ways that Africans can embrace the text in a positive way. I think it is just as important for readers of any text to analyze and address scripture that is found to be problematic in an attempt to come to terms with topics which are hard to swallow. This can often be more useful for a reader than just focusing on what is found to be positive within a text.

Okoye points out one problem he finds in reading Revelation that has made me realize I have a similar problem with the text. He considers total rejection of the state as a problem many Africans might find in the text. This is because early Christians in Rome would not be able to participate in politics in the first place without placing allegiance in the empire. However, with new governments being formed in much of Africa, Christian involvement in politics could be beneficial to its people. Okoye shows that sometimes complete rejection of the state is a bad thing especially if a positive change can be made by those involved in politics.

This idea has made me change the way in which I interpret Revelation from my perspective as a young, educated, white American. We are given the opportunity in this country to make a change if we, as Americans, really yearn for one. Of course, certain aspects of the American empire need to be resisted such as materialism and neglecting social justice issues but a more appropriate Christian application of the message of Revelation may be one of active resistance. Americans can stand up for what they believe in a way which Christians and Jews living in the Roman empire could not and so this problem with the text is turned into a positive message for me. It is a message of active resistance, not total rejection of the empire, in an attempt to bring New Jerusalem to Earth piece by piece.

Through this reflection I have found new meaning in the word John uses so often: "endurance." What effort does it take to sit and reject everything? That's easy. What takes endurance in America is standing up for what one believes, not sitting in total rejection. This is active endurance.

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Interpretation

I found Rhodes' presentation of cultural interpretation of biblical texts quite intriguing. Honestly, until this well thought out determination of the different cultural interpretations, I never really put much thought intot the importance of this type of interpretive "message seeker". I have been compelled by the Bible for a couple of years now, and have a constant demanding interest in determining the messages and the priority of the messages contained in it, whether explicit or implicit. Rhodes has now presented me with another way people have and can uncover themes in the Bible. She states that people interpret the Bible in order to make a difference in the world. I believe this is definitely a crucial presumption to interpreting the Bible. Rhodes gives examples of different cultures and how their status influences their cultural interpretations. She gives the lucid example of contrasting cultures, one from oppression and one from cultural positions of dominance, and how they often differ in their interpretations. The oppressed might interpret the text to develop strategies of survival, while the person from a dominant culture might interpret the same text to counter materialism. Rhodes also goes on to articulate that some people of dominant cultures might use the text to justify their conquest, destruction, and domination over other subcultures. I found this ironic because, while these people of dominant cultures are justifying their conquest with their interpretation, the victims of this conquest might be resorting to the exact same text for hope and/or God's assurance over evil and death. In Blounts essay, he elaborates on his belief that Revelation is definitely not concerned with an escapist viewpoint. He determines that the message is not to sit back and endure until Jesus comes to the rescue, but instead it is to witness to the kingship of Jesus in the face of the emperial claims of Rome and thereby to refuse to assimilate. I thought this interpretation was quite proactive and useful, but I also think that Revelation is informing people that regardless of whether or not things do change, Jesus will rescue us. Althought I believe this, it is important to realize nothing can change for God's will unless there is action.

I am taking the perhaps somewhat unusual step of writing this blog entry without having read all, or even most of the assigned reading upon which I’m supposed to be reflecting. (I’m also writing this from IHOP where I don’t have internet access, so will be posting it in the morning when I’m back on campus and have access to our trusty Hendrix wifi.) As of right now, all I’ve read in From Every People and Nation is the introduction by David Rhoads. I was particularly struck by this passage:

Cultural interpretation seeks to locate the place in life from which one interprets the Bible. A concept of “culture” in use here refers to the diverse expressions of particular communities of people in relation to the patterns of life, the values, the beliefs, and the stories/myths that hold a society or ethnic group together… Also critical to cultural interpretation is the place people have within their culture – referred to as the “social location” – in terms of race, gender, age, social class, economic level political position, education, religious affiliation, sexual orientation, health, and so on. Personal experiences and commitments also inform interpretation. Culture, national identity, social location, and personal perspective are all laden with power dynamic in relation to other groups within and outside the culture. Cultural interpretation recognizes that all expressions of Christianity are culture specific… People from dominant cultures are often not aware of the degree to which their understanding of Christianity is culturally conditioned and tend to think their beliefs are universal. (4-5)

This seems to me to describe the core of cultural interpretation. Inspired by this passage – and, in fact, by what seems to be the approach of this exciting book – I decided to make use of the tool presented in Appendix 3 which “enables people to reflect on the factors that may shape their reading experience” (241). I hope this will give me, and all of us, some clarity on the ways in which my reading of both Revelation and From Every People and Nation is shaped fundamentally by my social location.

1. Geographic/Natural Location

I am a transplant by way of the desert Southwest to Conway, AR. Conway is a medium-sized town in a very rural state in the Southern U.S., located approximately thirty minutes away from the state’s largest city.

2. Cultural Identity/ Nationality

I’ve lived my entire life within the United States and around people who shared that upbringing.

3. Social Location within Society

a. Race/Ethnicity

I am Caucasian. My maternal grandparents were both first generation Americans, born to Irish immigrants. My father’s family has been in New Mexico since before it was admitted as a state.

b. Gender/Sexual Orienation

I am a cisgender male. I am gay. I identify my sexual orientation as gay, and name my community membership as queer.

c. Economic Level/Occupation

I was raised in an upper/middle class family. I hold two part-time jobs and try to be largely self-sufficient, but still receive some support for my living expenses and know that I have the option to receive more whenever I need it.

d. Religious Affiliation/Conviction

I was raised as a Christian in the Presbyterian Church (USA) and remain active in PC(USA) congregations in both Albuquerque and Conway. In the past, I considered leaving the Presbyterian Church for a denomination that is more open and affirming to gay people, but I made the decision to stay.

e. Political Affiliation/Conviction

I am a registered Democrat and the only elections I've missed in the past three years are those in which my absentee ballot did not arrive on time.

f. Social Class/Vocation

I'm not totally sure what this means...

g. Other key factors

I am a young person, a student. I have completed almost 3/4 of an undergraduate degree and will probably be getting at least one graduate degree. I am able-bodies. I was born in this country and am a native speaker of English.

The appendix included five additional, more open-ended categories. I chose not to fill this out at this time for both time and practicality purposes. I believe that by making use of this exercise in this way, I have helped myself determine more precisely my social location so that I might better discern the ways in which it impacts my reading of the texts.


Monday, April 4, 2011

About Me

I greatly identified with González’ story. I also consider myself Protestant— I attend a small Disciples of Christ church in Juárez, Mexico. Most of my family, including my parents, are adherents of the Roman Catholic faith. In Mexico, over 90 percent of the population considers themselves part of the Roman Catholic Church. Upon coming here I faced the exact same problem as González. I am no longer an outsider because of my religion, but I am still because I am not the same race as most everyone else. When I have met Hispanic communities, I have been judged harshly because of my heresy (how dare I consider myself Protestant?). This is the general attitude towards Protestants in Mexico and I must assume many parts of Latin America. Protestants are judged and shunned, they are sinners who are in error, and they offend the “True Church” with their lack of faith on the Virgin Mary and the sacraments. As a child growing up Catholic, I heard horror stories of “Christians” (Protestants): they were sects that thrived on fanaticism, and sacrilegiously disbelieved the sanctity of the Pope— God’s Most High Spokesman. Just to list a few offenses, I assure you there are more. This creates some strain between people of a same yet different culture. It is striking how people who believe and worship the same God and the same Jesus of Nazareth can be so different.

González:

“I also became profoundly aware of—and angry at—the apparent inability of American foreign policy to understand the dreams, the pains, and the aspiration of other peoples.”(48)

I could not agree more with him on this and his following points. The World has felt the abuse of power of the United States’ government, and it is not a surprise to me that Americans are so discriminated against in other parts of the Earth. Now, I say this knowingly considering myself an American. Regardless of “identity issues” stemming from being a Mexican living in the U.S., I have come to realize in my years here that I too am part of this Country. The fact that I was born on the Texas side of the border, thus granting me immediate citizenship, helped me embrace my dual citizenship and culture.

He also writes:

“I soon learned that the interaction among cultures is a complex and often painful process, that cultures are not fixed realities, that they always exist and develop within the context of encounters with other cultures, that they both require and resist change, and that there is an inherent tribalism in all of us that tends to obscure these realities.” (49)

This reminded me of a book we read last semester in Dr. Sanders’ class: “Exclusion and Embrace” by Miroslav Volf. It is so true that it is intensely more difficult than imagined to make different cultures/societies accept each other fully. At least at first.

In any case, I enjoyed the tone and method of González’ work, as well as his many tidbits of interesting information and input.

I really enjoyed Stringfellow's claim about how all virtues a nation elevates and idolizes, whether it be military or even a sport, are subserviant to his definition of death, which I took to be, in essence, idolatry and anything that you let dictate any of the facets of your life other than God. Stringfellow reiterates this claim in the middle of his book by saying these virtues advert our attention from God and the truth of God's will and that we should not partake in these different kinds of death. I believe his rational behind this belief is obviously well developed and compelling, but I also sense that he might think that even watching a ballgame every so often is participating in a moment of death. If this is the case, I cannot say I completely agree with him. I believe that if you are worshipping a virtue of the nation, such as watching a basketball game, then you should cut it from your life. To me worshipping a virtue of the nation, basketball in this case, would be an ideal, event, or action that you are giving power over you and is hence causing you to be separated from God. Obviously this is when you need to omit it from your life. With this said, I also believe there is a difference between worshipping a virtue and appreciating or experiencing a virtue. Money for example is a prime example of a virtue of the nation that can definitely be idolized. Money in its essence is good; it can be used to do great things. But the love of money is evil. So I do not think that just because you are wealthy, you are obliged by God to give away all your money and live poorly. To reiterate this point of idolatry, Jesus (in Mark 10: 17-29) tells a wealthy man that it is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kindom of God. Also, I wanted to note that I found his emphasis on his viewpoint on the Word being an event quite effective and telling. I thought he summarized it well when he said that some literalistic interpretations devalue the humanity of the reader or listener by assigning the person a narrow and passive role depleted of the dignity of participation in encounter with the biblical Word which the vitality of that Word itself at once invites and teaches.
Reading Revelation is heavily influenced by the perspective from which one reads the text. Gonzalez tells of his perspective with a background of his relationship and encounters with the text. He grew up as a protestant facing judgement from Catholics as being fanatical and his church kept away from Revelation. He had a perspective of being a minority within a minority, much like John of Patmos.

Predictions of the Beast found in Revelation have been nullified by time according to Gonzalez. “Making Revelation into a sort of program for the latter days, they rob the book of any value or relevance for any other time,” says Gonzalez. Revelation is interpreted differently in its context. History repeats itself in patterns and this is what makes this interpretation relevant today.

Gonzalez applies Revelation to a contemporary interpretation by looking at its geopolitical order, economic order, and through cross-cultural encounters. Revelation applies to today because it was a political statement against Rome's “geopolitical order – and, by extension, of every world order that falls short of John's vision of the heavenly city.” Also, in connection with resistance to the political order Gonzalez suggests resistance to the economic order of Rome. The Roman economic structure exploited the poor and was advantageous to the rich.

Many Christians share the experience of the book of Revelation being disregarded or untouched and may blame this on it being too complex or too difficult to understand. However, Gonzalez argues that we are stuck as Americans between the great benefits of living in such a prosperous nation and resisting such an empire as John claims Christians must.

The Language of Resistance

In LaHaye and Jenkins’ Are We Living In the End Times?, we were presented with an interpretation of Revelation that relied very heavily on escapism; the apocalyptic text was supposed to teach us that earth is only our temporary home and we must do everything we can in order to be right with God in time for his arrival on earth, (the Second Coming). Blount’s article “The Witness of Active Resistance” looks at Revelation in a much different way, predominately through the lens of African American slaves before and during the Civil War. Rather than escapism, Blount focuses on language and visions, and their use as weapons against injustice and oppression. He says that the apocalyptic language in Revelation is “not the language or imagery of an escapist people who look to otherworldly visions to “drug out” their historical realities. Just as John foresaw a new earth as well as a new heaven, the slaves believe that God’s accomplishments in the heavenly realm could and would lead to liberation on the earthly one” (p. 34). Blount discusses how this is the language of resistance, not escapism, and it encourages change rather than avoiding reality for both the audience that the author John of the Book of Revelation was writing to and the African-American slave population. Of all of the articles assigned for today’s reading in From Every People and Nation, I felt like this chapter made the best argument about the similarities between the intended audience of Revelation and the cultural interpretation of the author of the article. As I studied in Synoptic Gospels last year, an African-American critique of the bible focuses on the injustices Jesus and his followers were subject to, and the hardships they had to endure in order to witness to others about who their God was. Blount makes a very good point at the end of his article, stating that, “The active witnessing, not the dying, is in the primary position. It is the witnessing that believers can control. They cannot control whether Rome will respond with censure, appropriation of property, and denial of social privilege, exile, or death. But they can control whether they will witness to the Lordship of Jesus Christ” (p.42). Both the martyrs in Revelation and African-American slaves can identify with an uncontrollable future; with each day comes a new possibility that they could die in their fight for freedom from oppression as God created them to be. Their endurance in times of oppression is key to their survival, not just in the physical sense but also more importantly in the spiritual sense. In both cases, “their religion was their resistance”(p.29).