Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Tina Pippin might fault me for calling John of Patmos a “product of his time”. I found her essay “The Heroine and the Whore” interesting. I had not considered that there could be no women in the new Jerusalem. She rests most of this argument on the 144,000 who had not “defiled themselves with women” being marked by God. One of the reserve books said that the number 144,000 represented completeness, this could mean that the complete group of God’s saved people had not been with women. If just being with women is bad then actually being a woman would be bad too. But the 144,000 were the firstfruits of the Lamb so its not clear if they are the only ones saved, (14:4). The redemption from political oppression overshadowed any potential redemption of females. Her essay made it seem like Revelation was so misogynistic that nothing could be gained from it. However in her conclusion she states that feminist readers can find hope in the unfinished story of the woman clothed with the sun and the hope that the destruction caused by the apocalypse would mean the destruction of all forms of oppression.


Like us John is a product of his social context. As a male who felt oppressed due to his religious beliefs in an intolerant empire I doubt concern for female liberation was his top concern and that shows in his writing. Since John’s vision of the future is not for women they would have to create their own vision’s. The resistance and hope for liberation from political oppression would have to have the hope for female liberation added to it.

“Male is the subject; female is the object—the object of desire that must be displaced in order for men to remain undefiled!” (130).

I had never thought to look at the Book of Revelation in a feminist perspective before taking this course; analyzing it in this light, though, provides for a rather unsettling feeling. Growing up in the Catholic church, I have long been frustrated with the limited influence women truly seem to have in my home church, as well as in Catholicism as a whole. Sure, women can be lectors, cantors, and Eucharistic ministers during the masses, and they can be on church committees like Arts and Environment that decorate the church for the different liturgical seasons, Prison Council, Catholic Daughters, etc. but what more can they really do to impact the church community?

Pippin defends the idea that the 144,000 in the Book of Revelation is a group of solely men, while woman are excluded very clearly. She adds, “Furthermore, the 144,000 are described in this way: ‘And in their mouth no lie was found they are blameless’ (14:5). This description removes the power of discourse from women. It assumes that only male speech is significant…[and] is depicting women as a defiling force” (130). This notion is particularly evident in the Catholic church, which also angers me. Personally, I would love to hear a woman give a Homily during mass; I feel that hearing a woman’s perspective on the readings we hear every week would be much more helpful than hearing a old man whom I have no real connection to preach incessantly on the dangers of reading Harry Potter.

One part of Pippin’s observations that I found interesting was that, “the irony of the grotesque burning of the Whore is that the Christian utopia is itself an oppressive world (for women)” (144). While I think Catholicism would become appealing to me again if women were able to have a more apparent influence in the church community, I am convinced the so-called radical changes I would like to see the church make will not happen; Revelation, along with other Biblical and religious texts, causes me to believe this since it seems to support the Catholic church’s current regulations on women’s involvement.

During class last Tuesday we discussed what a feminist critique of the Book of Revelation would look like, and to be honest, it was a bit offsetting. In Pippin’s chapter, “The Heroine and the Whore”, she analyzes many of the problems I have had with viewing Revelation through a feminist lens. Revelation seems to create a post-apocalyptical world with either no women in it or women so irrelevant they don’t deserve to be mentioned. As Pippin states, the text of Revelation is “not liberating for women, (or for men who care about the liberation of women)” (128); this leads me to ask a very Kent-like question- is there any redeeming aspects of the book of Revelation for women?

I found her argument about displacement to subordinate role in two spheres, (political and religious), very interesting and sadly, very true. John the Apostle’s attempts at undermining the powers of Rome did not challenge the skewed gender roles and patriarchal society that existed in Rome at the time. Instead, it demoralizes women and characterizes them as unclean because of their bodies. Pippin says that John uses women as scapegoats for all evil in Revelation, as he does with the Whore of Babylon character.

So what are we as women to do about this? It seems that reading Revelation only in a feminist lens creates a problematic view on the liberating nature of text. Maybe though, if we read Revelation as an oppressed people, not focusing specifically on our gender, but rather on our subjugated experiences as women, we will get a better understanding of the what the book of Revelation is about, a strong resistance against the powers that work towards oppression and unjust hierarchy. If we can view Revelation in this way, maybe it will be easier to read the text as a female concerned with the liberation of women.

should Africans suppor their goverments?

In his article, Chukwuma Okoye explains the perspective of an African reading the book of Revelation. He makes a very good point when he explains the problems many Africans have when reading the text. Many African prefer to take a more positive stance when interpreting the text. Some Africans tend to have problems reading the suggestion of rebelling against the state. In Revelations, the reader is advised to oppose Rome, but many Africans find it hard to do in the midst of establishing new governments. The African people were struggling to find a way to support their new governments and follow Revelations at the same time.
I feel like there is a big difference between supporting a state like Rome and supporting a possibly a government that actually upholds the ideas and principles of Christians. I feel that many African governments are in the beginning stages of their existence and it would be better for the people to support the government and try and try to make it acceptable. I think it is true that most governments are not problem free, but if the people simply stand by and let it become corrupt instead of trying to make a difference by participating. I have always believed that people who do not participate in the government, through activities like voting, have no right to complain that things are not going the way they should. Of course there are situations where governments are so corrupt that the people’s voice is never heard.

Okoye's "Dangerous" Interpretations

I found John Okoye’s take on the implications of Revelation for modern Africans refreshing. Rather than stopping at a liberationist reading and going on to hope that eventually the forces of oppression in his world would get theirs, he points out the potentially dangerous messages in even the most hopeful interpretations. First and foremost is Revelation’s – and Christianity’s in general – appeal to those who are on the bottom rung of society with promises of “pie in the sky when you die.” There is no question that this theology has been instrumental in reminding the oppressed that the more they suffer in life, the closer they are to God and the more favor they will be guaranteed in the next world – when they have lived out their usefulness to those who rule over them in this world. Okoye suggests that this reading isn’t helpful for those who live now and have little sincere expectation of Jesus appearing from the clouds during their lifetimes to strike down the forces of globalization, and I’m inclined to agree. Despite what many perceive to be exhortations against violent resistance in Revelation, Okoye recognizes that in the context of modern Africa, a slave to globalization, “resistance” must be active – the Christians’ only hope is to “engage with and neutralize the beast.” The only way they can do this is by participation in their governing structures, against the call to repudiate the authority of worldly government. If the people want to shake off the control of globalized economic and political forces, they will never do it by ignoring the government that these forces have helped establish. He is not advocating that they buy into the system that keeps them down, however; he is suggesting that only by acknowledging the inextricable tie between religion and culture that John considered “fornication” can the Africans begin to embrace their native culture and shrug off outside voices that say their traditional ways are backward or inadequate. Violence, as such, is not necessarily the answer, but nor is passive retreat from one’s environment and society, despite what ideas John of Patmos may have had  about reserving all loyalty and sense of duty for God.

A New Hope -> Return of the King -> The (New) Empire Strikes Back

Babylon has fallen. Awesome. New Jerusalem is coming. That sounds cool too! Ooo. . . wait. It is a gated community? hmmm, maybe I will pass. . . Why is New Jerusalem so great? Sure, onyx and carnelian and chrysolite and beryl are all really shiny. And bedazzled walls to keep out something (illegal immigrants?) sounds cool I guess, but I cannot get over those gates. Gates. Pearly Gates. "Its gates will never be shut by day-and there will be no night there. People will bring into it the glory and honor of the nations. BUT NOTHING UNCLEAN WILL ENTER. . ." (Rev 21:25-27) So a beautiful city, with full amenities for all who pay the homeowners fees and a really nice mayor can be yours IF you are let in. WooHooo! The Tribulation Saints fought off Babylon only to MAKE A NEW EMPIRE! If y'all are like me you probably cannot wait to sing songs to God ALL DAY singing Hallelujah and "Great and amazing are your deeds!" (Rev 15:3) Why would I worship Caesar when I know that if I have been really good I can praise God ALL THE TIME? Maybe the Romans knew this would happen and opted for Emperor worship because of it. And then my bad dream ends! It was just a dream! Hallelujah! The God of Jonah who is slow to anger and who cares about his creation saved me with multiculturalism and postmodernism! New Jerusalem is not THE new Jerusalem but only JOHN OF PATMOS' Jerusalem. What makes John's vision for a new world better than mine? Because it was divine? Anyone who has had a vision from God can refute my claim but until then divine won't get John anywhere with me. So why is John's New Jerusalem so much better than mine? There is no objective truth. There is no normal. Even if universals existed, John cannot prove he understands them. The point I am trying to make is that John of Patmos is just as socially located as everyone else who has ever existed so what makes his Jerusalem, his visions, his ideas better than any others? So here is the question. If we judge textual interpretations by the ethic they create, why not judge John of Patmos' visions the same way. Does Revelation lead to a positive world ethic or does it just create a new emperor, a new empire, and new outcasts?
In reading Tina Pippin's "The Heroine and the Whore: The Apocalypse of John in Feminist Perspective," I was struck by two things. First, I noticed just how much interpretive work could be done that I simply had not picked up on. Second, and on a related note, the ways in which John's text continues to enforce male dominant gender relations become even more noticeable.

I'll address the latter point in order to move back to the first. While I had picked up on the disparity between the role that feminine figures had played in this text and the role that male ones did, Pippin's evaluation was able to reveal a manifold of ways to get at an underlying paradigm in John's narrative that is oppressive for women. Making the case that women are presented by John only as objects or images of women, rather than subjects, Pippin exposes that while John may subvert the Roman order of social morality, gender relations remain perfectly acceptable. Women are not allowed to assume a status of power.

The most striking thing, for me, was her bringing to light the fact that all of the female characters are eliminated from the novel. The elect are all men. Even the Bride is re-characterized as a city. This leads me back to the first point I wanted to address. Though aware of most of these things, they had never seemed all that significant to me until Pippin placed them in the context of a failure for John to rethink gender roles. This text, more so than the rest, has helped me to further appreciate the value of cultural interpretation/the virtue of readings from multiple socio-historical locations.