Monday, April 11, 2011

Women in Revelation

Personally I found Tina Pippin’s very illuminating. Even though I am female, I never thought to read the book of Revelation in terms of gender roles. After reading her article I also agree with her conclusion, “that this text is not liberating for women (or for men who care about the liberation of women. As I said before, I have never given much thought about the portrayal of women in the text. As Pippin points out, there really are no “realistic” portrayals of females, only a stereotypical version. I never really thought about the idea that women are only represented as good or evil in the text. There is no medium or in between presented by John of Patmos. Women are either symbolically represented as a whore, seeping seduction or as a woman clothed with the sun bringing a political utopia. These are not real women; the women here are merely symbolic. John of Patmos doesn’t seem to think that women can even be a part of the New Jerusalem, which was particularly astounding to me. When reading Revelation before, I was almost obsessed with reading it in its historical context as a socioeconomic critique. Therefore, the quote “it is these who have not defiled themselves with women, for they are virgins” regarding the 144,000 (men)who “are on Mount Zion and who bear the name of the Lamb and the name of the Lamb’s Father on their foreheads,” surprised me when I read it in Pippin’s essay. It never crossed my mind that this excluded women. This is defiantly when read in 2011; however, when read in its historical time period it makes a lot of sense. John of Patmos wrote Revelation in a time period in which women were not thought of as equals to men. On the contrary, they were thought of as unclean as Pippin goes on to say. Therefore, it is almost comical to read revelations and become upset that John only uses stereotypical and degrading interpretations of women. This is simply a product of his time, and clearly not meant to be the main focus of the text.

What is myth.

In the writing of Pablo Richard, I was slightly confused on his actual point. There were multiple instances where I caught myself agreeing with him, and then he made a statement that just took me back. The emphasis on myth was an interesting take that we have discussed before. He mentions the God's of older religions such as the Canaanite God Baal. "Myths reveal the deeply rooted history of people. Myths are rational as concepts, but they express themselves differently. The failure to understand the historical dimentions of myth has led liberal and modern theologians to despise the literary genre of the apocalypse because they consider apocalyptic to be a deterioration of prophetic literature." (page 149) Richard is making a a good point that reading the myths of a culture allow the reader to look into that cultures past. The problem that I have is that myths are not always true. When reading ancient Greek mythology, one does not take it as fact, nor as actual history.

Due to the fact that I am reading Richard as an American, there are some differences in the way that I perceive what he is saying. He has a whole paragraph on the devil or Satan, and who this figure is. He explains that the Devil is a "mythical personification of evil, of iniquity, of anomie, of sin." (page 153)It is a myth, a way of expressing evil as a personified being? I struggled with his view of the devil and of his use of myth in this case. I don't understand if he is truly taking the events as fact, or if this myth he is talking about is just a way of looking at things and allowing one to understand the state of the world. I am sure that it is that latter, but in saying something like "it is a historical reality: it is the expression of supernatural forces of evil" (page 153) in referring to the devil, makes me curious as to where to go. How to resist this evil. In his concluding remarks he states that John is a theologian making an analysis of his time. This is something that I can agree with, as well as the feeling of hope he talks about as well.

Individual Ethics


I am very interested in the concepts behind the book From Every People and Nation. The concept to which I am most specifically referring is that of an individual ethic in the book of Revelation. This is a book, I think, about enacting change. But what is the change, exactly, that the book of Revelation is asking readers and Christians to bring about? And how?

Each author in From Every People and Nation seems to have a different conclusion to these questions, which I think creates both problems and possibilities for interpretation of the text. One problem this presents is, quite possibly, the lack of ethic within the text. If there is no correct, generally understood interpretation of the text, then a text can be used for any end. This could give the book of Revelation dangerous power and, in fact, has—I believe that Rapture theology is an example of this. Two supported interpretations could be in direct opposition to each other. However, this is a problem that cannot be solved as no human has the ability to discern absolute truth.

However, I do not think that these facts do not have to be absolutely negative. No one interpretation is going to be absolutely true to everyone who reads it, but it can provide guidance to individuals drawn to certain issues as related to their social position. A great example of this, I think, is Tina Pippin’s essay “The Heroine and the Whore.” This is an essay which finds an ethic of “resisting a violent, male future” within the book of Revelation. I found this article particularly interesting due to its very specific focus of studying the archetypes of femininity within the book. I do not think that the book of Revelation is about this issue specifically as she reads it and I would have most likely never have picked out the same issues that she did. However, I like that this text does not have to be interpreted as though it was written for a specific target. It is flexible and accessible to a wide variety of people. Otherwise, I feel, it would not belong in the Biblical canon.
Martin's womanist reading of Revelation argues three main points. First, from the perspective of a womanist critique, one is placed in solidarity with the oppressed against the domination of imperialism. John's critique, with a focus to his comment on the sale of "slaves and human souls," demands the "revision of social ideals and power arrangements" (105). Further, the womanist critique brings out the way John uses "signifying" techniques to subversively undermine the language that empire speaks about itself, telling a new story which depicts its practices, again with a look toward the placement of human life in equivalence with other saleable goods. Finally, this allows us today to see the ways in which we still occupy spaces of imperial domination and the subjugation of bodies.

In reading Martin's essay, two things occurred to me. First, it seems that cultural interpretation and "identity" theories in general have done a lot of good. They express the ways in which we are no longer so readily attached to a supposedly "objective" perspective which in fact was expressed the perspective of a dominant socio-historical position in our economic and political life (to roughly paraphrase Marx). Second, it seems that there are some major drawbacks to the emphasis on this multiculturalist or "interculturalist" paradigm. Although Martin herself, along with other authors in this volume, have expressly stated that the identities with which they are operating are not essentialist, I would have to disagree. Rather, I would say that postmodernism, while not responsible for it, has certainly made possible the spawning of innumerable essentialist identities. That is to say, the authors of this volume want to take up certain commitments to identity politics, certain wholesale identities regarding cultural, ethnic, etc. groups which fix characteristics and qualtities of individuals, in order to entertain liberatory actions. Because postmodernism cannot allow for any fixed identity, one must remain at a certain "distance" from this identity. However, in effect this identity is appropriated and treated as if it were not as problematic as it has been made by the very discourse out of which the authors are interpreting. The problem, specifically, is that the very identities which the authors affirm are constructs of dominant power structures and language games within which those bearing that identity were/are subjugated. Assumption of these identities is seen as a way to "reclaim them," but they cannot be reclaimed because they were never anything but restrictive--there is no authentic identity behind the construction.

Thursday, April 7, 2011

The Womanist Perspective

The Womanist reading was intriguing for me because it offers something more than just a feminist reading towards the book of Revelation. Although feminist readings and interpretations are a nice way to look at texts, I feel that I can get more from the womanist perspective. Although she says this in her conclusion, Martin categorizes the womanist approach as identifying with those who are oppressed and siding with those who are the minority against the Roman Empire. Also, she says that the Womanist critique draws from the Black tradition in how John protests in Revelation. She also says that a Womanist critique reads Revelation from a heurmenutical standpoint. Martin opens up with telling her readers what she intends and how she wants her reading to be like a ‘looking glass’ to Revelation. I do, however, like that she specifies with how we are to understand the meaning of our readings, it is “throught the interaction of author, text and reader”. Although Martin does say this I also believe in reading Revelation and other texts through the historical lens but that does not make me closed off from reading them through another lens because the ability to read from different perspectives and lenses helps people to be more empathetic towards others. Martin also shows us the difference in Ezekiel’s references to slaves as compared to John’s. For instance the list of commodities that has made Rome or Babylon rich, in Exekiel’s list slaves among the first listed of commodities because they are so valuable whereas John puts them in descending order so as to open our eyes to this social critique of the practice of the slave trade. John is not in support of the slave trade and recognizes that these people that are enslaved have souls just like everyone else.

In Clarice J. Martins' interpretation she mentions that John of Patmos expresses a minority opinion in the face of the hegemonic, oppressive powers of the Roman Empire via signifying on Rome. She interprets Revelation 18: 13 as the commodification of slaves by the Roman Empire being a mirror image of the African America slave trade and how it is parallel with the "Signifying Monkey Trope". In her comparison of this "Signifying Monkey Trope" she determines that the signifying is usually done in an enigmatic and witty way to protect the writer from the oppressor being signified against. Martin summarizes Brown's poem about the "Signifying Monkey Trope" and states that it illustrates how a vulnerable monkey could use shrewd language to expose and undermine the arrogance of the powerful lion and at the same time protect himself. This analogous perception of why John might have written Revelation in the cryptic manner that he did raises a few questions for me. I think that this presumption that John was indeed writing in such a symbolic style due to his apprehension is flawed simply because the "Roman Empire" would not be foolish enough to not uncover the hidden symbols behind the text. In other words, there is no way John could have genuinely thought that by him being clever in his symbolism, he would not be punished. In addition, I do not think that he wrote in this ambiguous style due to fear because he was in exile already. I realize that the Roman Empire could have still persecuted him even though he was in exile, but he could have written the book pseudonymously. Also, if John was true to what he seems to encourage in this text-to resist the Empire openly and expect to be persecuted and almost embrace this persecution-then wouldn't he be perfectly fine with saying "Rome is a Whore" instead of using symbols?

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Revelation 18:11-13 in Clarice J. Martin's View

I remember the first time that I read that passage in Revelation— I had to go back and re-read it twice. I made a mental note to figure out why slaves/human souls were included on the list of goodies. Clarice J. Martin intelligently utilizes the striking metaphor of a mirror (looking glass) to explain her experience as an African American woman reading Revelation 18:11-13.She explains that in this passage she saw herself and her people reflected because of their past condition as slaves in America. She explains that the past cannot be forgotten and is “the future’s looking glass” (Reuel Denney). To begin her study she states her method of analysis. First she affirms that all critical interpretations are relative to the author’s philosophical approach and personal background. This fits right in with the general ideology of this book, judging by Rhoads’ introductory chapter. She also explains in this section that her interpretive lens is that of “womanist”. She gives a little history of the womanist theological movement, which I appreciated since I did not previously understand the difference between “feminist” and “womanist”. I have read some of the work of Alice Walker (the woman who conned the term), and I am glad to see the connections.

Martin writes that “slaves and human souls” in Revelation 18 mirror African American slavery. However she does not mean that they aresone hundred percent similar. She goes on to list not only the similarities between the slave systems of Greece and Rome, but also some major differences. A major dissimilarity that I found interesting is that in ancient Mediterranean cultures, slaves were not indentified by their race or ethnicity. Slaves usually came from all sorts of ethnic and racial backgrounds, and through many mediums (such as war, kidnapping, and piracy). Slaves also performed all sorts of tasks, from manual labor to intellectual work as secretaries or managers. They also worked side by side with “freed” women and men. She explains that a similarity is that slaves were treated with force (often violent force) in order to curb their attitudes. Also, slaves were fundamentally dishonored people. She goes on to examine the authorship and cultural setting of the Book of Revelation in order to arrive at the conclusion that slaves’ testimony is essentially one of “resistance and fearless resolve in pursuit of a liberated life”(106).