K. K. Yeo’s essay on his three readings of Revelation piqued my interest because Chinese culture after the Cultural Revolution is a social context that is extremely different from my own. Chinese Christians have to make to choice of whether to work with their government or belong to “unregistered” churches that resist any sort of involvement with the Chinese government. I like that Yeo points out the difference and similarities between resisting the Chinese government and Roman empire and Chinese resistance of Western imperialism. He says that in John of Patmos’s time Christianity was not a huge cultural influence. Christianity’s spread into China from Western culture was imperialistic, but in the 20th century the Chinese have made it their own. Chinese Christianity in some ways seems more sincere than Christianity in America. In China religion is not an ideal to the culture like it is in America. Their brand of Christianity is more comparable to John’s than LeHay and Jenkin’s brand. LeHay and Jenkins had to call other cultures and forms of government the beast. Chinese Christians who do not want to work with the government resist that beast and those who try to work with the government resist the beast of corruption because the know the government is “fallen” (a la Stringfellow). Yeo distills one broad message from Revelation that he thinks can be applied to humanity be it Christians trying to cooperate with the government or resist. This message is that the world is not what God wants it to be and Revelation’s vision of new Jerusalem gives hope that the world will one day be what it is meant to be according to God. I think this leaves room for Christian individuals to interpret what they should do in their different social contexts. If they think they can work with the government to make the world better they can do that.
This is the blog of the "Revelation and Resistance" course at Hendrix College. Your comments are welcomed and invited.
Wednesday, April 13, 2011
Panentheistic Outlook
In Rossing’s article, “For the Healing of the World”, Rossing argues that the Book of Revelation leads us towards a lifestyle of eco-consciousness, preservation, and ethical environmentalism. Although I did not agree with all of her reasoning, (it seemed like her section on God’s woe/ouai was a bit far-fetched in my opinion), I thought that as a whole, the article did a lot of really good things to help tie two major issues in today’s society, injustice towards humans and the oppression of nature, together in order to further both causes in their search for redemption. Throughout reading Rossing’s article, I couldn’t help but wonder if she might have been influenced by Panentheism, (the belief that God exists and is in and extends beyond every part of nature). I think that this is best shown in her discussion of Revelation 22:2- “On either side of the river was the tree of life with its twelve kinds of fruit, yielding its fruit each month; and the leaves of the tree were for the healing of the nation.” She talks about how the healing does not come directly from God but through the created world, and if Panentheism in fact influences her, this would mean that God is working through the created world that gives healing. Therefore, the healing in Revelation is acted out through both God and nature. I also found her presentation of the two cities in contrast, Babylon and the New Jerusalem, really interesting, especially her focus on the empire itself not as evil but as its exploitation of power as evil. I really like the idea that there is “an integrated spiritual and social vision” for the world, and that the Book of Revelation is focused on the interrelationships between nature and religion; I appreciate Rossing’s take on the ecotheology present in Revelation and her acknowledgement of the similarities between our call as humans to care for one another as well as for the earth. I found her presentation of the two cities in contrast, Babylon and the New Jerusalem, really interesting.
I think Richard, of all the approaches focusing on liberation or otherwise attempting to apply Roman imperial power to a contemporary context, did the best job so far. By focusing on a close reading of the text and interpreting John in terms of myth and symbol, he allows for certain dynamics and relationships to be at issue in John's condemnation and call for resistance. In this way, an appropriation by contemporary readers becomes more plausible, because what is at stake is not the specific Roman practices of idolatry and governance but the domination of peoples by a total imperial system of political and economic power.
Tuesday, April 12, 2011
Chinese in Babylon?
I was particularly interested in the article by Yeo, who seemed to really want to balance working with the system such as China, and also opposing the government when needed. It seems to Yeo that, when the government is not being imperialistic, one can work with it to better the nation and world. However, he does not seem to mention much of how to oppose the government when it is needed. In our own Western culture, we see many of China’s policies, especially it’s lockdown on free speech, to be wrong and detrimental to getting anything done within the public sphere. However, one must also realize how values in other cultures work. For example, as an American, I value free speech, even though I have to deal with on a daily basis opinion that I do not agree with or even want to tolerate. However, in China it seems that there are other values at work. For example, the Maoist ideology, while idealistic, still has a prevalent role in Chinese life. The Chinese probably have a care and a sense of togetherness that America could ever achieve, given the fact that many of us are so opposed in goals. To the Chinese, fighting the beast can mean fighting the people the people of China as a whole. Since the government is part of God’s creation, one must work with it when it is able to produce care and help for those who need it. Yeo made me doubt my own radical interpretation of Revelation, mainly because these Chinese do not have much option other than working with the public sphere. It would not do much good in China to oppose the Chinese government it seems, and maybe to work closer to the New Jerusalem, there is room for work within these spheres.
Rossing's Revelation on Revelation
At first I was skeptical of Rossing’s argument that Revelation is about hope. Nevertheless I read on and I came to realize that I was focusing too much on the destruction and gore that we see so much of in Revelation. Rossing then made me realize that there are messages of hope and a renewal of the Earth in Revelation. Rossing’s message of hope and renewal comes from the end of Revelation where John is describing the New Jerusalem. This message of renewal is something that we all at some point in time have wished for and yearned for but we may never thought possible, Rossing and John tell us that it is possible because of God. He will be the one to restore peace and prosperity to those oppressed by the Empire. The only problem that I have with Rossing is simply that she does not find her hopeful and Earth Renewing argument throughout Revelation she only finds it towards the end of Revelation when John tells us of the New Jerusalem. Her argument towards Lahaye and Jenkins in her essay is compelling. She argues about how rapture theology can hurt more people and the Earth instead of helping them. I agree with her on this especially because if we are to live on this Earth that was provided for us we have the responsibility to look after and care for all of its inhabitants and its creatures. We should not live on the Earth wishing to belong in heaven we should live on the Earth and enjoy the time we have on it. In order for us to do this we need to help our Earth live a longer life by loving it. John’s portrayal of the New Jerusalem offered his readers hope, especially when hope seemed almost completely lost to those being oppressed by Babylon/Rome.
Monday, April 11, 2011
Promised Peace
There is a lively debate over whether John’s Revelation replaces one form of imperial domination with another and whether his lauded hero, the slain lamb, is an emperor in sheep’s clothing. I side with those who argue that John’s application of imperial metaphor to the slain lamb does not resolve in an alternative politics of domination. On this account Revelation destabilizes domination by offering a cross-examination of attempts to achieve utopian bliss through the application of imperial might, even that form of utopia apocalyptically guaranteed by divine omnipotence.- Page 73
While reading Maier’s Coming Out of Babylon, all I could think about was our class discussion last Thursday. Granted, earlier in Maier’s text he brings up the point that whatever you’re searching for in literary analysis you will usually find so I probably am being very biased in my opinion on the reading, but I couldn’t ignore all the times Maier mentions peace and conflict in Revelation and how Jesus’ second coming is not about a new empire brought to replace the old empire, but rather a new way/ethic of living. It would be very difficult to argue that the Book of Revelation does not focus on violence; its’ imagery and language emulate violence and a period of war and conflict. The author John characterizes the Roman government as evil as well as the Pax Romana, which Maier describes as “the often brutal military and economically exploitative rule of “pacified” peoples by a conquering power” (72). Maier’s understanding of the Book of Revelation is influenced greatly by his double vision as both a German and a Canadian immigrant, therefore living in an American society under the American government does not prejudice him. I think that he is forcing us to see through his eyes what our society looks like through his analysis of what John claims the Roman society looked like. Just because Rome promised peace doesn’t mean its citizens got peace, and instigating peace through harsh brutality will not cultivate peace by any means. As Maier claims, the second coming of Jesus is not about wiping out a whole people through violence but about bringing peace back into the world as it was created to be.