The contextualization of the apocalyptic texts is certainly relevant, and Horsley provides us with a way to see the historic implications that are deeply important to understand. However, I do not see these texts as certainly only about their historical contexts, in fact that would make little sense. If this was a revolt of the scribes, then why would they be writing such symbolic and image heavy text for a Jewish audience that is probably mostly illiterate? Why would scribes feel the need to “revolt” at all within the texts when this would obviously only bring comfort to a select few individuals who would be able to understand the imagery? It seems to me that if the scribe wrote this he must have had a metaphorical inclination, otherwise what is the point other than making his intellectual scribe buddies think better about the state of things? I am not trying to limit Horsley's argument here, certainly his thesis is important, however since what this means for the future is not included, we are missing a big part of the story. This would be like analyzing Full Metal Jacket as only a product of the situation in Vietnam at the time. While it is certainly the case that Full Metal Jacket was a reflection on these events, it also certainly makes a statement about the dehumanization that goes on in any war in any time period. While I suspect that Horsley would be conscious of this problematic part in his thesis, and probably is limited to length because of his necessity to prove his scholarly arguments, I also think that this political dimension of these apocalyptic texts and what they mean for today is complex, and deserves a more deeper analysis by scholars. Horsley alludes to this a bit in his conclusion for Chapter 5 “the religious and political-economic dimensions were inseparable.”I think that the the apocalyptic texts have a political message that needs to read, and maybe could apply to us today.
P.S. Although not relevant to this analysis of the reading, I decided it would be fun to post a song by the band Hellhammer, who use a lot of biblical imagery in their songs. This one in particular deals with the apocalypse, so it makes some references to characters mentioned in Revelation such as Gog and Magog. However, these bands often reverse this imagery and make Satan the eventual winner in this cosmic battle. Even black metal guys are creating there own interpretations of the apocalyptic texts (even if it isn't very faithful to the biblical text)!
To read the lyrics, click here!
No comments:
Post a Comment